Recent Events At Bitcoin Market
dwdollar starts a discussion: Recent Events At Bitcoin Market.
dwdollar, founder of Bitcoin Market, the 2010 exchange matching its users' orders

On March 17, 2010, a BitcoinTalk user asked Dustin Dollar (dwdollar) how many people were actually using his market. Bitcoin Market, the exchange Dollar had built, had started taking real money the day before. His answer was three sentences long.
Ddwdollar (BitcoinTalk post, March 17, 2010, 5:07:01 PM UTC)There are 9 people signed up but only 3 have made a deposit so far. Myself makes 4. Looks like we had our first real trade around noon!
It was a market of four people. Even so, its operator did not set the price. Sellers and buyers each placed their own orders, and the site matched them. Two months earlier, in his first announcement, Dollar had described what he was building: “It will be a real market where people will be able to buy and sell Bitcoins with each other.”
Dollar registered on BitcoinTalk on January 15, 2010, and the announcement was his first post, sixteen minutes later. He expected to have a website with a basic framework up within weeks, and asked people to bear with him.
Two months later, on March 16, he decided it was time “to try some real trading”. Users could deposit dollars, bitcoins, or both. He was using PayPal for the cash, “until I find something better”. The site’s SSL certificate was self-signed, so browsers would show a warning. He had opened an account himself and placed a bid for 500 bitcoins at $0.0067 each, which he took to be NewLibertyStandard’s current rate. The whole order came to $3.35. One sentence in the post reads: “This isn’t a donation!”
The other places where bitcoins could be turned into cash at the time are set out in the analysis of the exchanges that came before Mt. Gox.
On March 20, Dollar started a thread on ways of exchanging bitcoins for cash and back. He listed what each service was doing: NewLibertyStandard took PayPal payments directly, Martti Malmi was working on several payment methods for customers to choose from, and his own site moved money in and out through PayPal. Then he quoted a post that Satoshi Nakamoto had written seventeen days earlier, proposing an exchange site that holds only the bitcoin side of each trade and never touches the cash. Three days later Satoshi replied in the thread, setting out the advantages of linking Bitcoin to Liberty Reserve and Pecunix, whose payments could not be reversed.
On April 25, Dollar changed how the market worked. Cash would now go straight from the buyer to the seller by PayPal, and he would hold the bitcoins until the seller confirmed the payment. “This is experimental,” he wrote. At once theymos replied and named the weak point: “PayPal payments can be easily reversed.” Dollar agreed: “Charge-backs are a weakness of this system.” He offered two possible remedies, a rating system for users based on their past trades, and making buyers keep bitcoins in their accounts as collateral. He also explained why he was staying with PayPal: “I haven’t seen a fool-proof exchange method yet,” and “PayPal is fairly common to all.”
Dollar posted the code behind his site on the forum. On April 6 he shared a small Python class that sent commands to the Bitcoin server, and said it would be the basis for automated transactions on his site. Malmi answered that an existing library did the same job in three lines. Dollar took it with a laugh: “Well… at least I got sirius-m to share some of his mojo.”
On July 16 he posted the code that actually handled deposits. He had meant to clean it up first, he said, but did not know when he would have the chance. He added that it “probably isn’t the best approach (after talking to Satoshi a while back)”, and went on: “But, it is battle tested. Why fix what isn’t broken (yet)?”
In the early hours of July 12, Dollar started a thread titled “Bitcoin Market growing pains”. “This caught me with my pants down,” he wrote. “Trading may or may not be conducted tomorrow”. The post does not say what had happened. In his next post, a day later, he thanked three people who had offered to help and said he had decided to buy a new machine and keep hosting the site himself, because there were “a lot of security issues” he wanted to work out before moving to a remote server.
Six days after that, on July 18, Mt. Gox opened.
The weakness he had admitted in April became real in October. On October 8, Dollar posted a warning headed “BCM SCAM ALERT”. It began: “Bitcoin Market is experiencing a deluge of complaints from sellers.” The trades had come mostly “from PayPal accounts that appear compromised”, and many of the trades from the previous two days would turn out to be bogus. He closed the market for the rest of the day and stopped taking new members. “Other exchanges are reporting similar behavior,” he added.
Three days later he proposed a way for exchanges to share what they knew about scammers. Something as simple as a mailing list might do, but it would have to be “somewhat exclusive”, or it would hand the scammers the same information.
On October 14 he reopened registration, with three rules for new members who wanted to use PayPal. One of them capped PayPal purchases at 500 bitcoins a week. The post was last edited twelve hours later. In that version every rule is struck through, and a line in bold has been added: “EDIT: THIS NO LONGER APPLIES”. A later post in the same thread gives the reason: “After today, I see this isn’t going to work. Registration is closed once again.”
The same post carried one more piece of news. Development of the current Bitcoin Market had ended, and “a new platform is in the works.”
On December 31, Dollar opened the new Bitcoin Market for testing. The post begins: “The new Bitcoin Market is up and it’s full of bugs.”
The rebuilt site included the remedies he had listed in April. After each completed escrow trade, a user could leave a score of +1, 0 or -1 and a comment, and anyone could see who had rated whom. The currency pair was now plain “BTC/USD” where it had been “BTC/PayPalUSD”, and dollars could come in through Liberty Reserve, PayPal or the mail. A single market offered two kinds of order: automated orders, which the site settled itself, and escrow orders, which buyer and seller settled between themselves.
On June 6, 2011, Dollar wrote an apology “to anyone who was ‘burnt’ by the recent events”, and especially to older members who might have struggled to get an invitation. “Open registration was a bad mistake.” PayPal trading had been taken off the market, and if PayPal did not “take the proper side” in many of the disputes, he wrote, “I am officially done with them.” The post ends with this sentence.
Ddwdollar (BitcoinTalk post, June 06, 2011, 5:16:09 PM UTC)Bitcoin will flourish with or without PayPal.
The real name comes from his own site. In August 2011 the “About Us” page of Bitcoin Market named the developer of the site, and the owner of Bitcoin Market LLC, as “Dustin Dollar (a.k.a dwdollar)”. His BitcoinTalk profile shows 202 posts. Twenty-seven of them, from January 2010 to June 2011, are collected here. Between 2017 and 2019 the same account started a number of threads promoting tokens. Their subject has nothing in common with the posts of 2010 and 2011, and they are not treated here as Dollar’s own record.
From beginning to end, Dollar’s record is about PayPal. In March 2010 he would use it until he found something better. In April he called its reversals a weakness and kept it anyway, because most people had it. In October the fraud arrived, and he closed registration, opened it, and closed it again within twelve hours. In June 2011 he wrote that he was done. Satoshi had told Malmi in February 2010 that payments which can be reversed do not suit an exchange. Dollar reached the same conclusion in his own market, and it took him more than a year. That year was not a detour. For someone who had nothing but PayPal, his market was where bitcoins could be bought.
28 entries / 5 threads
dwdollar starts a discussion: Recent Events At Bitcoin Market.
dwdollar starts a discussion: ===>>>BCM SCAM ALERT<<<===.
dwdollar starts a discussion: Scam Alert Network?
dwdollar starts a discussion: Registration On Bitcoin Market.
dwdollar starts a discussion: Bitcoin Market 2 Testing.
dwdollar starts a discussion: Bitcoin Market growing pains.
Thread started by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 20.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 92.
Bitcoin Institute ↔ Satoshi Nakamoto, Martti Malmi, NewLibertyStandard, Dustin Dollar, Jed McCaleb
Four exchanges opened between October 2009 and July 2010, none of them Satoshi's: NewLibertyStandard, Malmi's bitcoinexchange.com, Bitcoin Market and Mt. Gox. Satoshi advised from the sidelines.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 234. after msg1976.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 242. after msg2078.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 417. after msg3579.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 63. after msg633.
Thread started by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 87.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 130. before msg1130.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 149. before msg1646.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 215. before msg1779.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 626. before msg6542.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 83. before msg810.
Context post by dwdollar in BitcoinTalk topic 342. before msg4508.