Bitcoin Institute

Hal Finney → Andy Greenberg (Forbes), March 2014

1 messages Forbes Hal Finney, Andy Greenberg, Dorian Nakamoto March 25, 2014 — March 25, 2014

Hal Finney to Andy Greenberg: "I deny categorically these allegations" (March 2014)

I must be brief. The reason I was skeptical about Dorian Nakamoto is that he didn’t match the picture in my mind that I had of Satoshi. I pictured him younger, as he was giving the impression of youthful vigor. Then there is the language Bitcoin was written in, C++. Satoshi was a master of the intricacies, and I’ve only seen this in young programmers. It seems hard to master C++ if you didn’t learn it while you’re young. As I have learned more about him, there are details that don’t add up, such as his care for an aging mother, which might cause financial strain.

As for your suspicion that I either am or at least helped Satoshi, I’m flattered but I deny categorically these allegations. I don’t know what more I can say. You have records of how I reacted to the announcement of Bitcoin, and I struggled to understand it. I suppose you could retort that I was able to fake it, but I don’t know what I can say to that. I’ve done some changes to the Bitcoin code, and my style is completely different from Satoshi’s. I program in C, which is compatible with C++, but I don’t understand the tricks that Satoshi used.

As far as your theory that I knew Dorian, that is unlikely because I lived in Temple City more than a decade ago, when Bitcoin hadn’t even been dreamed up. Again, I categorically deny any familiarity with Dorian Nakamoto.

About this record: Text as quoted in Andy Greenberg's Forbes feature of March 25, 2014. The article does not give the email's date or headers, and does not say whether the quoted passage is the whole message. The date shown is the article's publication date. Finney wrote the email after March 6, 2014, when Newsweek named Dorian Nakamoto as Satoshi, and before the article appeared.