Bitcoin Institute

Yes, the Bitcoin.org Site and Forum were Down

26 messages BitcoinTalk Bruce Wagner, kiba December 1, 2010 — January 10, 2011
Bruce Wagner December 1, 2010 07:36 UTC Link to this message

The Bitcoin.org site and associated forum were down for about 9 hours today, I think.

Some of us, using the IRC Chatroom, have expressed concern for this single point of failure.

There has been discussion about somehow making a distributed Forum… or an auto-syncing forum…

But, in the meantime, we have reacted swiftly.

On this page  http://www.bitcoinme.com/discussion-forum.html  I have listed no less that FIVE Bitcoin Forums we now have access to.   

It would be great to cross-link as much as possible, so that in the event of a major outage, people would instantly know where ELSE they could go for information.

What do you think?

Bruce Wagner December 1, 2010 07:47 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: MagicalTux on December 01, 2010, 7:40:34 AM UTC

I agree, currently in case of down of bitcoin.org the only remaining official information source is IRC, I think alternative urls should be either known, or included (for example on an help page in the bitcoin client) 😊

Even if they were just listed, in as many places as possible…  Users would likely “bookmark” them in their browsers…  But it’d also be nice if they had access to a copy of the list-of-forums on several major Bitcoin sites…  (similar to how there are lists-of-exchange-sites all over the place).

MagicalTux

I’m thinking of adding a wiki on bitcoin.in (or one of bitcoin.at or bitcoin.it) where this kind of information will have its right place 😊

That sounds like a great idea too.   The more well-written resources we have, the less chance we’ll ever get so cut off again… as we were today.

Didn’t it feel odd…!?   I think a LOT of people were feeling very cut off from their community…   It can be a little like crack…  😊

kiba December 1, 2010 13:49 UTC Link to this message

So, are people actually serious about this idea?

kiba December 1, 2010 14:15 UTC Link to this message

Despite the downtime, we achieved 315 posts that last day of November. 😄

kiba December 1, 2010 14:23 UTC Link to this message

A failover would be nice. So we can continue talking while the original server is getting its shit together.

kiba December 1, 2010 16:28 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: bitcoinex on December 01, 2010, 3:45:43 PM UTC

Just do backups.

Have nothing else, if something happens to the information will not be affected and community survive.

But a backup is just that, a backup.

There’s no communication on the forum happening until SMF is running.

kiba December 2, 2010 00:15 UTC Link to this message

So, have we reach a decision making point on backup?

I think the consensus is:

  1. Offsite backup, encrypted. Keys held by elder members.

Nice to have.

  1. Failover solution. Some way to get the forum back up and running.
kiba December 4, 2010 02:52 UTC Link to this message

How often is this synced?

kiba December 9, 2010 15:17 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: TylerJordan on December 09, 2010, 2:20:08 AM UTC

I run the earthsociety.org portal and the digital coin forum (small beans compared to bitcoin forum!). Would be willing to give a subdomain with ftp access to a maintainer to manage a mirror of bitcoin forum.

So how hard it is to get the forum data mirrored, anyone?

kiba December 9, 2010 16:53 UTC Link to this message

Yes, we should do something better than a HTML scrape.

kiba December 11, 2010 17:59 UTC Link to this message

This is the second time that the forum goes down. We should definitely do something about distributing and mirroring it.

Bruce Wagner December 11, 2010 18:09 UTC Link to this message

Has anyone yet figured out why it is going down?

 No one seems to even know who runs this site!?   ❓

Starting today, I will be double-posting every comment I post, on both this forum and the bitcoinme.com forum.   If I have time, I’ll post it on the other 2 forums as well… bitcoin.in and the Google Groups Bitcoin group.  

 We need our forums of communication to be decentralized as well.

kiba December 11, 2010 18:13 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: brucewagner on December 11, 2010, 6:09:31 PM UTC

Has anyone yet figured out why it is going down?

 No one seems to even know who runs this site!?   ❓

It’s Sirius and he speculate that there were too much memory usage. In other words, the bitcoin community is growing.

kiba December 11, 2010 18:53 UTC Link to this message

For the last recent downtime, Sirius did an upgrade on the server. No worry.

Bruce Wagner December 11, 2010 19:00 UTC Link to this message

That’s good to hear.  😊

 It would be nice if he could read a wrecked the page to a down for maintenance page.

( I love android voice to text. That mistake was so cute I thought I’d leave it in. 😊  )

Bruce Wagner December 12, 2010 00:37 UTC Link to this message

I recommend adding this to your forum signature…

    ( alternate bitcoin forums: http://bitcoinme.com ● http://bitcoin.in ● http://goo.gl/bzze1 )

…so everyone knows that there is more than ONE bitcoin forum on the internet.

kiba December 12, 2010 01:30 UTC Link to this message

Or we can Sirius here and discuss about how we’re going to mirror the bitcoin forum database…

kiba December 14, 2010 05:29 UTC Link to this message

Resurrecting this topic; we can’t get complacent about this subject.

So, the simplest solution to this problem is to simply back up the database to somewhere safe, no?

Can we get Sirius onboard with this idea?

kiba December 14, 2010 06:43 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: sirius-m on December 14, 2010, 6:25:05 AM UTC

Automated backups of the database to a remote location would be useful if something unexpected happens with the hosting. Any ideas how to store the backups? Maybe encrypt them and distribute to multiple servers around the world. Distributing them through a single gateway (Dropbox, Tahoe-LAFS?) would save bandwidth.

That would be a good start. Tahoe-LAFS would be nice to use also. (There’s also possible synergy between Tahoe and Bitcoin)

I think we can handle trusting the seniors not to abuse the database data.

Any possible timetable?

kiba December 16, 2010 02:15 UTC Link to this message

I think we could implement Shadow’s idea.

Sirius?

kiba December 20, 2010 15:20 UTC Link to this message

How long will this process take?

kiba December 21, 2010 17:20 UTC Link to this message

Thanks for resolving this issue!

That mean that the senior develooper can redeploy to a different server with the backups, if neccesary. Right?

How many servers are serving as backup/mirror?

kiba December 30, 2010 03:36 UTC Link to this message

So, how mirrors are backing up the forum db?

Is there a way to do a db dump of non-sensitives information?

kiba December 30, 2010 23:34 UTC Link to this message

Er, how many mirrors are backing up the database?

Bruce Wagner January 10, 2011 22:08 UTC Link to this message

Perhaps we should build a Forum-Backup capability into the standard bitcoin block chain… so that a current backup of the entire forum database is embedded into the block chain.   😉