Bitcoin Institute

[FORTUNE] The clock is ticking on Bitcoin

6 messages BitcoinTalk Bruce Wagner June 17, 2011 — June 18, 2011
Bruce Wagner June 17, 2011 18:34 UTC Link to this message

[FORTUNE]   The clock is ticking on Bitcoin

http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2011/06/17/the-clock-is-ticking-on-bitcoin/

This is a link to the original article in its current state (right-click save-as): 

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/993053/Created/Personal/The%20Clock%20is%20Ticking%20on%20Bitcoin%20%5BFortune%5D.odt


BRUCE WAGNER’S RESPONSE TO THE FINISHED ARTICLE FOLLOWS:

Below is my latest email back to the author of the article, Daniel Roberts…


On our phone call…  we left off at number 8 below.


I THINK YOU SHOULD CALL ME URGENTLY!        xxx-xxx-xxxx

(1)   Meze Grill does not sell burritos.  

(2)   “…although so far not a single customer has paid this way.”   //   NOT TRUE.  We paid for our dinner just the other evening in Bitcoin there.

(3)   “…and many of its uses have nothing to do with Silk Road.”  //   BLATANTLY MISLEADING.   0.0000000001% of its use has anything to do with Silk Road.   NO ONE I KNOW has ever used Silk Road.  It’s blatantly misleading to imply that ANYONE uses Bitcoin for such things.   It’s absolutely irresponsible reporting.

(4)   ”… In simple terms, here’s how it works: After downloading a desktop software client (the most popular one is Dwolla)…”    //   OMG.  This is sooooo inaccurate.   (A)  There is no need to download a desktop client.   (B)  Dwolla has nothing to do with Bitcoin.   (C)  Dwolla is not a desktop client.

(5)   “…each Bitcoin is associated with a URL where users can see the entire history of the coin’s use, including every user that bought or sold it…”   //   NOT ACCURATE AT ALL.   This is terribly inaccurate and misleading.

(6)   “Bitcoins have had volatile ups and downs but never a full crash.”   //   VERY MISLEADING.  Bitcoin value has gone UP form $0.06 to about $20 today.   That is UP UP UP.  No crash at all.

(7)    “Now there are even other Bitcoin-like currencies, such as Namecoins, which are bought with Bitcoins and used to pay for domain name hosting. Some traders believe the biggest potential is in the limitless creation of these e-currencies.”     //   OMG OMG OMG   I NEED TO CALL YOU.  THESE STATEMENTS ARE GOING TO MAKE YOU LOOK LIKE A FOOL!

( 8 )    “At the moment, Bitcoins can’t really be used at any mainstream retailers. According to a wiki list of businesses that accept Bitcoin, you can use the currency to buy real goods and services, but we’re not exactly talking about Amazon.com (AMZN).”   //   OMG OMG OMG   YOU CAN ALREADY USE BITCOIN TO MAKE PURCHASES ON AMAZON.COM  !!!!!!!!   via TradeHill.com… TODAY!

TRADEHILL IS NOT JUST CONVERTING BITCOIN INTO AMAZON MONEY.

TRADEHILL ALLOWS YOU TO COMPLETELY MAKE THE PURCHASE ---- USING ONLY BITCOIN ---- WITH ONE CLICK.   THAT IS NOT JUST BUYING AMAZON MONEY.

And many many many online retailers are quickly following suit with the Amazon + TradeHill system.

(9)   You mention burritos again…  which Meze Grill does not sell.

(10)   “If they really wanted to ensure they aren’t losing money from sales paid with Bitcoins, they’d have to watch the exchange rate closely and adjust their price every single day.”    //   This is being solved by new Point of Exchange startups which now accept the correct amount of bitcoin for the dollar amount, sell the bitcoins for dollars instantly, and deposit the US dollars into the merchant’s account the next day.   This problem will have been solved totally by the time your article goes to print.

(11)   “If the USA wants to shut it down,” Wagner reasons, “the Internet has a way of detecting censorship and rallying around it. They could block Bitcoin transactions, but it would be censorship.”    //   Those were two separate unrelated statements… you combined into one statement.

The first one, ACCURATELY, was:   “If censorship happens on the internet, the internet by its nature sees that as an error and routes around it.”

The second one, ACCURATELY, was:   “Most likely, No, the US government could not completely stop the Bitcoin network.  To my understanding, the only way the Bitcoin network can be stopped is to completely stop the internet.  And the only way to completely stop the internet is to make it illegal and confiscate 100% of the computers.  Even then, as long as two computers exist --- in any other country on Earth --- the internet will still exist, and thus… so will Bitcoin.    If the USA decides to vote for internet censorship --- like they have in China --- it will not slow down Bitcoin at all.”

THAT is what I actually said.

(12)   “But in fact, because users all have identifying web IDs, the government could rather easily identify users today, make it illegal to operate a Bitcoin node, and drive users away with the same scare tactics that the content industry uses on illegal downloaders. And censorship protests or not, there isn’t much American traders could do.”   //   1000% INACCURATE.   Bitcoin users DO NOT HAVE IDENTIFYING WED IDs… NOT AT ALL!   Only about 2% of the Bitcoin users I know actually operate a “Bitcoin node”.   That statement is ridiculously misleading.     Even if it were made illegal in the USA, it would most likely not even cause a blip in the Bitcoin network, or the value of a Bitcoin on the global market.

(13)   “The reality is that a currency that has no regulator, trades on an open exchange, and can be easily stolen is one that won’t sit well with lawmakers. So whether Bitcoins are a risky investment or not, expect Uncle Sam to keep the average American consumer from ever getting to make that choice.”     //   WOW.  This conclusion really sounds like you were TOLD to write this article…  and TOLD what conclusions to make.

The word “Misleading” seems to be a key concept of this article.

Sad.   Very Sad.

Bruce Wagner  •  OnlyOneTV  •  http://onlyonetv.com  •  xxx-xxx-xxxx

On Fri, Jun 17, 2011 at 12:51 PM, Daniel Roberts <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Bruce, thanks for speaking to me. I enjoyed getting to know you by phone! The story is up and being well received… See anything factually wrong? I see some Bitcoiners tweeting it negatively but that’s because, I imagine, they disagree with our angle/conclusions, which is fine.

But do let me know if there are any errors! http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2011/06/17/the-clock-is-ticking-on-bitcoin/

All the best to you,

Daniel Roberts

On 6/17/11 11:46 AM, “Bruce Wagner” <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Try do better than BusinessWeek just did…

I just asked him if he’d like my spelling and accuracy corrections.

      http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/11_26/b4234041554873.htm

I strongly recommend letting me review it just before you post it… In case any language is misleading, etc.

I won’t complain…   I just wanna help make you look good.

:-)

Bruce

Bruce Wagner  €  OnlyOneTV  €  http://onlyonetv.com  €  xxx-xxx-xxxx

On Fri, Jun 17, 2011 at 10:38 AM, Bruce Wagner <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Right now is good. I’m on cellphone, but that’s ok.  Yes? xxx-xxx-xxxx

On Jun 17, 2011 10:34 AM, “Daniel Roberts” <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Ah, okay. Unless right now is good?

On 6/17/11 10:03 AM, “Bruce Wagner” <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Sounds great. Can we make it 11:00am ET…? xxx-xxx-xxxx

Bruce

On Jun 17, 2011 9:00 AM, “Daniel Roberts” <[e-mail address]> wrote:

Great, thanks Bruce. Basically I already have a nearly complete story but I have a couple gaps perhaps you could help me fill in: just as a preview, they involve whether there’s anyone that has made big returns by investing in BTC, and if that’s public/who/how much, and the basic fact of whether exchanges like Mt. Gox or TradeHill charge a transaction fee, which I haven’t had answered yet. Could I call you around 10:30 EST? Thanks so much.

Best,

— Daniel Roberts Fortune

1271 Ave of the Americas, 18th Floor, 1853B New York, NY 10020 xxx xxx xxxx [e-mail address]

Bruce Wagner June 17, 2011 19:33 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: PLATO on June 17, 2011, 7:26:56 PM UTC

(5)   “…each Bitcoin is associated with a URL where users can see the entire history of the coin’s use, including every user that bought or sold it…”   //   NOT ACCURATE AT ALL.   This is terribly inaccurate and misleading.

bruce, this IS accurate, please try to fact check a bit…

here is the history of my bitcoin roadtrip donation address: http://blockexplorer.com/address/1Dj1SocbbH9Lbb9aTdqSHB9AAjhdxNNZha

you can click on any of the transactions to see where they came from and where they went. true, they are bitcoin addresses, not names. but, just because no one has made a blockchain miner to dig out juicy info doesn’t mean it’s not there.

The way he phrased it is INACCURATE.   Change one word… and the whole sentence is untrue.

“…users can see the entire history of the coin’s use, including every user that bought or sold it…”  IS ABSOLUTELY UNTRUE on several levels.

Quote from: niemivh on June 17, 2011, 7:20:11 PM UTC

Scary thing is that the smear campaign is just getting started.

The best two things that the main stream media can do to keep people away from Bitcoin:

  1.  Pretend like it’s really easy to get your wallet stolen (and it might be for the computer illiterate)
  2.  Allude to a vague illegality regarding the whole thing.  We see that with this article that they are fear-mongering based on complete lies that “You have an ID and can be tracked” and “it will be illegal in the near future so don’t even bother” with the clear insinuation that you might be going to prison.

Total fear-mongering.

But like I always say, the best money isn’t even in creating money out of thin air; it’s keeping people afraid.

AMEN!

Quote from: niemivh on June 17, 2011, 7:13:24 PM UTC

Well that’s because the main stream media is owned lock stock and barrel by the same interests that have everything to lose by widespread BTC adoption.

And AMEN!

Bruce Wagner June 18, 2011 10:20 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: flug on June 17, 2011, 8:24:51 PM UTC

I think the most unfounded and agenda driven part of that article is actually the title and the conclusion.

(First impressions & last impressions are strongest. The stuff in the middle that was actually discussed, people won’t remember.)

“The clock is ticking on Bitcoin With recent exposure bringing the online currency to the attention of wary lawmakers, expect to see Bitcoins disappear.”

ending with..

“..expect Uncle Sam to keep the average American consumer from ever getting to make that choice.”

None of this is substantiated or discussed properly. It’s just assumed. Agenda driven!

This is how they do it. They just state things. And people suck it up in their millions.

This is ABSOLUTELY TRUE.

This reporter told me --- BEFORE THE INTERVIEW --- that, yes, he’d be interested in any factual corrections to the article … but suggested that most criticism will be coming from people due to his take/angle.   

In other words…

When he was assigned this story, there were two Givens:

(1)    The Topic

(2)    The Conclusion (i. e. They call it his “Take/Angle”)

And this is before any research…

When he still didn’t know a Bitcoin from a toaster oven.

The Boys who Own the Media… own the media.

Bruce Wagner June 18, 2011 10:34 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Jaime Frontero on June 18, 2011, 4:22:33 AM UTC

bruce?

you are kind of a fanatic - and that’s ok.

but let me give you a tip - because you’re becoming a very high-profile, go-to guy as far as the media is concerned.

get contracts for interviews.  real contracts, with… like… lawyers.  and don’t give any more interviews without final cut: that is, it doesn’t print or air without your ok.  the slant of a piece on Bitcoin is irrelevant; but you need to keep a firm hold on context, exact quotes, and facts.

Interesting Advice.   Who to contact about this?  What type of attorney?  Referrals?

Also, please note that the email in the original post here was written in anger and in haste.  I apologize for the caps and the omg’s…  

It was also written AFTER the article was published.

It was not the “input”, as someone suggested.  

It was my response after reading the finished article already published.

This article was obviously a smear campaign to make Bitcoin look bad.

Bruce Wagner June 18, 2011 10:42 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Phil21 on June 18, 2011, 5:24:02 AM UTC

Bruce - re-reading my post, it looks like this was a personal attack on you, and I guess it somewhat was.  This was not my intent and I do apologize.  I actually enjoy reading your stuff and think you bring a ton (way more than I have, or am likely to!) of value to the community.

I just hate to see Bitcoin develop a PR problem because we as as a community can’t do something as simple as having reasonable, respectful, and truthful conversations with detractors.   Trying to tell people not a single person has used a bitcoin for Silk Road purchases for example I believe is counter-productive to the cause - it’s a completely made-up fact that is demonstrably false.

Otherwise, let the revolution continue!  It takes all types, and the community diversity is what will make this idea take hold and become strong! 😊

-Phil

I said:   Not a single person I KNOW has used Silk Road.

Bruce Wagner June 18, 2011 13:50 UTC Link to this message

Yes.  Obviously.  I can’t know who uses it without telling me…

But for the sake of brevity, the way I phrased it was:  No one I know has used Silk Road.

And I think the point is clear.

The fact that people use it, is irrelevant to the fact that no one I know has ever told me they’ve used Silk Road.

It’s important to let people know that:

(1)    I have had contact with many many many Bitcoin users.

And

(2)   Not one of them has ever told me that they’ve bought anything on Silk Road.

Exactly one person has told me that he has been able to get the site to load.   But that he’s not planning on using the site --- only taking a look at it.  He also told me that it was an unbelievable task to get through all the layers of security --- just to be able to read the web page.