Bitcoin Institute

Do Bitcoins have Serial Numbers (effectively)

2 messages BitcoinTalk Insti June 16, 2011 — June 16, 2011
Insti June 16, 2011 11:32 UTC Link to this message

I’m a bit confused by your quoting.

Anyway:

If I put 2 coins from address ‘A’ and 1 coin from address ‘B’ into a new address ‘C’ Then I spend the 3 from ‘C’:  1 to ‘D’ and 2 to ‘E’

Where did the coin in address ‘D’ come from? ‘A’ or ‘B’?

Insti June 16, 2011 18:38 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: jonone100 on June 16, 2011, 11:49:47 AM UTC

for clarity here is the actual message https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2965.msg41319#msg41319

Ok. How does that thread not already answer your question?

As for what I was trying to say, as usual theymos says it better in that thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2965.msg52466#msg52466

Quote from: jonone100 on June 16, 2011, 1:11:11 PM UTC

**Is a bitcoin uniquely identifiable against any other bitcoin? **

I think the answer to this question is ‘no’.

Think of each bitcoin address as a bucket of water. If a bucket is created which contains 50 liters of water. If you combine 10 of these buckets into a big 500L tank, then take out 1L of water from the tank, you cannot tell which bucket the water started in. So therefore the water is not uniquely identifiable. It is the same with “bitcoins”.