Calculating Bitcoin Value...
One thing that concerns me is how people are calculating how much it costs to generate a Bitcoin. For instance, NewLibertyStandard has determined the value by “the yearly average of the bitcoins generated per day divided by the yearly average of the amount of dollars spent per day on Internet and electricity or (bitcoins generated)/(cost of bitcoins).”
This is a good point. I was just trying to come up with a number for how much it costs to produce bitcoins. Here is my data on electrical use, depreciation of CPU, and internet connection:
Electricity CPU running at 100% when no other tasks (most of the time) gives about 800 khash/s Time to generate avg block - 27 hrs Power required to run whole computer - 0.4 amp, 44 W (say CPU takes 80% of this, 35.2 W) Electricity used - 27hrs * 35.2 W = 0.246 kWh Electricity cost for me is about $0.08/kwh Cost for 50 bc is 10.246*0.08= $0.1968 cost per coin is **$0.0003936 **
CPU depreciation Life of my average computer is about 5 yrs Since I usually don’t average above 50% cpu for the time it is on. I predict the extra time at 100% will take the life down to 3-4 yrs When I bought it last year the machine was $700 When I replace it it will likely cost $350 Cost per year originally was $350/5years = $70.00/yr Cost per year with reduced life is $350/4yrs = $87.50/yr Cost 1yr = $17.50 Cost per block at 27hrs = $0.0539 Cost per coin =** $0.001078**
Internet connection My bitcoin nodes each use about 2kbps My total practical bandwidth is 100kbps This connection costs me $25/month or $0.90/block % of bandwidth used is 2% so cost/block is $0.018 Cost per coin is $0.00036
Totals Electric - $0.0003936 Depreciation - $0.0010780 Internet - $0.0003600
Cost/coin - $0.0018316
I would appreciate feedback to improve this model since it may be helpful to new bitcoin users.
Related entries (1)
Related entries
I’m not sure about your math on the electricity used. Formula I found to find kWh used is (Watts * Hours Used) / 1000. Someone else chime in, but your usage I think may be 3-4 times too low.
Mine would be (100*27) / 1000 = 2.7 Kwh for 50 BC’s At my $0.11/Kwh that is $0.297 per 50 bc’s.
$0.00594 per BC just for electricity. (Interestingly enough, the approximate going rate for BC’s on the bitcoin market)
I think you are right. My figures for electricity are low. My power supply says 1.6a but it powers a laptop so some of the power goes into charging not just running. I figure it must be charging at least 2x faster than it is draining because the battery can be almost gone and when I plug in the power it will charge while still running bitcoin at 100% CPU. Originally I had thought that it was 4x greater charge rate than drain rate since it will recharge while in use. However, after your post I am rethinking this. It takes about 3 hrs to charge while in use and about the same time to drain a fully charged battery while watching movies. I am sure bitcoin does not take as much power as a movie with intensive graphics use but for the sake of argument lets drop the charging factor to 2x the drain factor. This means that the laptop is fairly energy efficient compared to my old desktops and only uses 0.8a or 88W to run. I believe most of this power goes to the CPU since I have an lcd screen and nothing else like video or hard drive being used most of the time.
Also I think your electric costs are closer to avg given this chart from DOE:
http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/table5_6_b.html
Therefore your formula would give (88*27) / 1000 = 2.376 kWh for 50 coins At your rate of $0.11/kWh that is $0.26136 / block or $0.00523/coin
There was a mistake in my math. I agree with your formula and don’t know how I got what I did. Thanks for the catch. Even with my old numbers the cost/bc should have been about $0.0019 instead of $0.0003
So adding in the other costs
Electric - $0.0052300 Depreciation - $0.0010780 Internet - $0.0003600
Cost/coin - $0.0066680
Related entries (1)
Related entries
Well, after the slashdotting it seems blocks are being generated about 3x faster due to all the new nodes. This means my computer has to work 3x longer to generate coins.
It has been said that bitcoins do not have a commodity value tied to them like gold. I agree with this but there is an indirect value in the electricity, CPU depreciation, and ISP costs spent to make the coins.
In a previous post I estimated my costs at about $0.006/BC.
Now I would say since my cost of production has tripled the price I am willing to pay has at least tripled to $0.018/BC.
I say “at least” because for me, I want to accumulate enough BTC value that I can use it to send money securely as intended. Currently the value of the BTC is low and I have to keep buying coins to get enough value to send my money. As the value increases I won’t need to buy as many coins to send the same money.
Related entries (1)
Related entries
I added a new answer to the FAQ (
https://www.bitcoin.org/faq#Where_does_the_value_of_Bitcoin_stem_from_What_backs_up_Bitcoin) about the value of Bitcoin.Bitcoin has value because it is accepted as payment by many. The initial market value was achieved when people speculated, that because of its properties, the currency would be accepted by others later on.
When we say that a currency is backed up by gold, we mean that there’s a promise in place that you can exchange the currency for gold. In a sense, you could say that Bitcoin is “backed up” by the price tags of merchants and currency exchangers – a price tag is a promise to exchange goods for a specified amount of currency. Of course, price tags may or may not be as long-term promises as those made by central banks or governments.
It’s a common misconception that Bitcoins gain their value from the cost of electricity required to generate them. Cost doesn’t equal value – hiring 1,000 men to shovel a big hole in the ground may be costly, but not valuable. Also, even though scarcity is a critical requirement for a currency to be useful, it alone doesn’t make anything valuable. Your fingerprints are scarce, but that doesn’t mean they have any exchange value.
Would you say that like any fiat currency the bitcoin is generally worth at least what it cost to make it? Even in times of massive inflation, paper money can still be burned. Obviously it is usually worth much more based on market demand but the lowest value it should command is that which was expended for its creation.
Would you say that like any fiat currency the bitcoin is generally worth at least what it cost to make it? Even in times of massive inflation, paper money can still be burned. Obviously it is usually worth much more based on market demand but the lowest value it should command is that which was expended for its creation.
Why?
It has been said that the economy is more like an organism than a machine. I agree with this. An organism grows and adapts to its environment but does not do well in restricted environments. It is impossible to calculate what a few billion people will do next year. Each has free will and can complicate the picture.
Just to clarify, for me the value of bitcoins is at least what I have to pay to get them. This may not be true for someone else who does not really want to use them and is only trading for investment purposes. I am trading to get enough value to actually use the system as intended as an anonymous payment method. Most items I would want to buy, like digital gold, are expensive and I need a lot of money transferred to bitcoins to do it.
Just in case this is helpful to anyone else who is in my same position I would like to share what the current value is to me.
As of right now, the difficulty to generate has gone up 4x since my last entry where I listed the value at $0.018. Therefore I am willing to pay** $0.072** and have been doing just that on the exchange. Apparently there are lots of other people who feel the same way because the ask price is now up to $0.084.
Edit:
I saw some new information on electricity consumption that looks quite a bit more accurate than what I had:
http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=403.msg3574;topicseen#msg3574
I may need to revise my figures.
Related entries (1)
Related entries
I have heard of Ludwig Von Mises as one of the founders of Austrian economics but only as other people have referenced his work. I should check out the site. It sounds like something I would agree with.
