Bitcoin Institute

Lending at negative interest rates. (People like bigger numbers.)

6 messages BitcoinTalk Insti, kiba August 2, 2010 — August 4, 2010
Insti August 2, 2010 08:14 UTC Link to this message

In a thread in the general discussion forum (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=617.msg6771#msg6771) bytemaster made what I think is an awesome post. Unfortunately the thread then wandered in a different direction, but I thought the post merited further discussion, and this was the best place for it.

Quote from: bytemaster on July 31, 2010, 3:22:59 AM UTC

In a highly deflationary environment lenders would lend money at negative interest rates and still make a real profit. 

The real problem is that people like the idea of numbers getting bigger more than they like the idea of smaller numbers doing more.    Who wants to take a nominal pay cut! 

So to counter this mental handicap of society, it may make sense to simply debase the currency via a “stock split/rebasing” to keep a basket of goods a constant nominal BTC value.   In effect this would make the “real return on investment” caused by deflation tangible to the thick headed public that thinks 4 pennies is better than 1 nickel because 4 > 1. 

Assume the number of goods in the economy grows at 5% per year. 

Normally Joe earns 100 BTC this year and a gallon of milk costs 100 BTC.   The economy grows by 5% thus the price of milk would fall to 95 BTC; however, the nominal BTC value of Joes labor also fell and his boss gave him a 2% nominal pay cut and the average Joe gets ticked (too stupid to realize he really got a 3% raise). 

Now if you “rebase the currency” then the price of milk will remain 100 BTC, Joe’s boss gives him a 3% raise and the average joe is “happy” even though his employer really gave him a real pay cut!  But because the price of milk stayed flat “joe” feels richer (and he IS richer because all of society has more goods), but not as relatively rich as he would have been under deflation.   

Where as if we did not do any “stock splits” Joes salary would have fallen to 98 BTC but milk would now cost 95 BTC. Clearly hie is richer.     

In my view it is a GREAT THING when someone loses their bit coins because the value (read purchasing power) of lost coins gets evenly distributed among all other coins. This is a WIN for all of society except the poor sap who lost his coins.

Discuss.

Insti August 2, 2010 08:19 UTC Link to this message

Red did have a question about it which I’ve tried to answer myself:

Quote from: Red on July 31, 2010, 6:15:28 AM UTC

In a highly deflationary environment lenders would lend money at negative interest rates and still make a real profit.

This seems quite silly as opposed to not lending the money and making even more real profit.

Perhaps I don’t understand what you are saying?

If everyone just hoards the economy stagnates. By lending out bitcoins it is possible to stimulate growth in the economy.

As a simple example:

Say 1 bitcoin buys you 1 loaf of bread, and the entire economy is based on comparisons to loaves of bread.

Scenario 1: At the start of the year I have 1000 bitcoins, I lend out 100 for 1 year at -50% interest. This stimulates the economy to grow 100% At the end of the year, I will have 950 bitcoins, but they are worth 1900 loaves of bread.

Scenario 2: 1000 bitcoins, I lend out 0. The economy doesn’t grow at all, At the end of the year, I will have 1000 bitcoins, but they are still only worth 1000 loaves of bread.

There is a lot more math you can do to cover more complex scenarios and make more acurate estimates of growth, but I think this illustrates the general principle.

kiba August 3, 2010 03:03 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Red on August 03, 2010, 2:58:44 AM UTC

Expanding upon “bunk”

As a simple example:

Say 1 bitcoin buys you 1 loaf of bread, and the entire economy is based on comparisons to loaves of bread.

Scenario 1: At the start of the year I have 1000 bitcoins, I lend out 100 for 1 year at -50% interest. This stimulates the economy to grow 100% At the end of the year, I will have 950 bitcoins, but they are worth 1900 loaves of bread.

Scenario 2: 1000 bitcoins, I lend out 0. The economy doesn’t grow at all, At the end of the year, I will have 1000 bitcoins, but they are still only worth 1000 loaves of bread.

There is a lot more math you can do to cover more complex scenarios and make more acurate estimates of growth, but I think this illustrates the general principle.

Lending 100 BTC and having it double the economy is an example equivalent to saying, “And then monkeys fly out of my butt…”

So here’s more monkeys!

Scenario 1:

YOU: At the start of the year you have 1000 bitcoins, you lend out 100 for 1 year at -50% interest. This stimulates the economy to grow 100% At the end of the year, you will have 950 bitcoins, but they are worth 1900 loaves of bread.

ME: At the start of the same year I have 1000 bitcoins. I lend out 0. You stimulate the economy to grow 100% At the end of the year, I will have 1000 bitcoins, but they are worth 2000 loaves of bread.

I win!

Scenario 2: Neither of us loans coins. The economy increases We tie in value.

Or the economy is stimulated less than usual, and you end up with less total wealth growth between the two of you.

Insti August 3, 2010 08:08 UTC Link to this message

Thanks for your well thought out replies guys.

Quote from: bytemaster on August 03, 2010, 4:43:58 AM UTC
  1. Red was right, lending at negative interest rates will make a real return, but not as big of real return as not lending at all!

I do not agree that this is necessarily true.

It probably doesn’t matter if no-one lends anyway. We’ll just end up with the anti-Tragedy of the commons (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons) where it gets overgrown because no-one is going to let their cows out onto it.

People in general are REALLY bad at observing the negative effects of things that do not happen.

Insti August 3, 2010 15:59 UTC Link to this message

So do we NEED an inflationary economy for anyone to actually do anything other than sit at home on their pile of bitcoins  with a shotgun?

kiba August 4, 2010 22:16 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Red on August 04, 2010, 6:20:20 PM UTC

For the record, I’m a pragmatic libertarian. Believe but do your own math. Math works. Empirically validated functions rule. Philosophy is easy to twist to any whim. That is my philosophy! :-)

Just be careful of bad math that cause you to believe in something that isn’t true. Your map does not correspond to the territory and all.

You don’t want to be like Paul Samuelson with his economic textbook touting the idea that the Soviet economy will surpass the USA’s economy. He didn’t understand how they work at all.

The Austrian schools merely derive their economic from deductive logics. So there is a way to disprove them. Just explain their logical mistakes.