Bitcoin Institute

Would you run a client with a built-in "tax"?

3 messages BitcoinTalk Ground Loop, kiba July 23, 2010 — July 24, 2010
Ground Loop July 23, 2010 21:16 UTC Link to this message

If you could download a Bitcoin client that computed hashes at twice your current rate, but sent 5 of every 50 bitcoins awarded to the software developer, would you run it?

Ground Loop July 24, 2010 01:17 UTC Link to this message

Interesting replies.

I don’t have such a client — just to clear that up.

What I’m getting at is this:  If BTC were highly valued, and a very clever-but-selfish developer had an exceedingly fast client (say, someone gets CUDU running on all cylinders, or hand-crafts SSSE3 for i7), would they be better off retaining the program for their exclusive use (during inflation), or offering it for ‘sale’ by effectively charging a fee for every find.

I suspected it would be more profitable to distribute it with a small fee, but the reception sounds a bit… less favorable.

kiba July 24, 2010 02:14 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Ground Loop on July 24, 2010, 1:17:31 AM UTC

Interesting replies.

I don’t have such a client — just to clear that up.

What I’m getting at is this:  If BTC were highly valued, and a very clever-but-selfish developer had an exceedingly fast client (say, someone gets CUDU running on all cylinders, or hand-crafts SSSE3 for i7), would they be better off retaining the program for their exclusive use (during inflation), or offering it for ‘sale’ by effectively charging a fee for every find.

I suspected it would be more profitable to distribute it with a small fee, but the reception sounds a bit… less favorable.

The difficulty would just goes up and make it harder for you to generate bitcoins.