Losing Critical Mass and Call to Action
The rate of posting is low this month, and there are few real members creation. We don’t have enough critical mass for takeoff. I don’t know if we’re losing momentum, but just to make sure, double the amount of energy into increasing the mass for takeoff. We can’t expect others to do their share of the work, we must do it ourselves. Slashdot so far is only our signifigant source of new members blast. We may need a couple more blasts to go to the rest of the J curves but we shouldn’t relies on it to make our success. If anything, user blasters will be the product of creating our own “lucks”.
Keep showing up on IRC and forums. Keep building web services. Keep writing letters. Most of all, find yourself a niche. Division of labor has made our wonderful civilization like this. Let seize it in our new society.
I know I also need to do my part too, so I shall contribute in some small way. I’ll shall begin working on a prediction market no later than this Wednesday.
I think many people loose interest when they see that it is very difficult to generate bitcoins. But buying bitcoins isn’t so hard, so getting them is not the problem. I think more in the lines of being able to spend them. Sure, there are some nice ways to spend them, but many things are a bit of a niche currently (relative little people have real use for it). If I have a look in the first few topics in the Marketplace, I see financial related stuff and lotteries/poker related stuff. None of which I would be interested in.
I think you’ll need to express your needs and see if people are willing to offer and try to get started. However, at this point, we have too few users to facilitate much trading since there is a lack of coincidence between what you want and what resources they have.
Two months is too long to realize that generating bitcoin is a waste of time, I believed. It’s not a plausible hypothesis.
However, this is September so school is probably a plausible hypothesis pulling bitcoiners from the community a little while.
Another hypothesis is that the community has already say much about bitcoins and that we’re running out of stuff to post. That’s probably implausible though but I don’t know how to determine this.
Another thing that would help bitcoin adoption:
python, perl, php libraries and common code for interfacing with bitcoin.
For example, Perl or Python code that verifies that “17NdbrSGoUotzeGCcMMCqnFkEvLymoou9j” is a valid bitcoin address, and “098123409813lkjasdflkjasdflk” is not, would be useful to anyone wishing to implement a bitcoin web interface.
Possible coding bounty.
OK, to help boost bitcoin, I’ll sell my PS3 and all my PS3 games for bitcoin at a reasonable rate. What is the best place for me to advertise a sale, other than just posting this forum?
Kiba, what was your luck with trying to sell gameboy games?
http://biddingpond.com?
I forgot about that. However, I have yet to figure out the shipping cost and how to do it as well, On Saturday, I think I will be able to put up an auction.
I think the current status of coin generation difficulty and the arms race of private-source GPU coin generation has discouraged some people’s interest in the coin generation game/lottery which - rightly or wrongly - has been the motivation for a lot of people’s involvement. It also seems to be a symptom of a meta-flaw in the project design, because open source projects want to ENCOURAGE the contribution and sharing of code, but the nature of the coin generation process seems to inherently reward and incentivize closed-source forks. Another set of concerns is the possibility of non-conforming clients exploiting the system (as seems to have occurred somewhat recently causing the 0.3.9 update) and the resiliency of the network to malicious behavior, and the potential fragility of your bitcoin bank account if you mess up handling your wallet file. Last but not least is the meta-issue of understanding how to deal with your local laws and regulations concerning taxes and money.
I love the idea of bitcoin, but I have donated all my bitcoins to the EFF donation thread now and am no longer actively participating in the bitcoin economy because of how the above issues apply to me. This is not intended as criticism of bitcoin, just as a user reporting why they are no longer using the software currently.
- I’m not interested in running multiple computers at max cpu usage for weeks to try to generate a rather trivial value of coins, especially when I know GPU users have vastly higher efficiency
- The mechanics of keeping my wallet files private and constantly backed up with a fresh copy gives me “data stress”
- All software has bugs. Software that is related to money is an inevitable target of attacks, and there is no FDIC backing or legal system remedy available in the case of problems
- I don’t really know how to document and declare transactions in bitcoins for legal and tax purposes and I’m scared of getting it wrong
In other words, I see costs/risks to using bitcoin and trying to participate in the bitcoin economy without seeing practical benefits other than how much I like the idea of bitcoin and think its cool software. I want bitcoin to succeed, but my current evaluation of my economic self-interest is that I have no reason to run the client and no reason to purchase bitcoins. I also do not feel motivated to “promote” bitcoin because that makes me feel like I am basically working to advocate the economic interests of those who already hold large quantities of bitcoin wealth. The have/have-not dichotomy is another structural issue: “come join our economy! you can be a peasant!” is a hard marketing sell.
Related entries (1)
Related entries
((lots of good stuff removed)) The Madhatter
Thanks for your well considered response. I agree with all of your points. I want to re-emphasize I am a bitcoin supporter and have had only good experiences using the bitcoin software, bitcoin community websites, and discussing on this forum! I take bitcoin very seriously as a fundamentally important project - the idea of a decentralized currency, a p2p economic system, is inherently exciting, and bitcoin’s design and implementation seems brilliant once you understand how the pieces all fit together.
All of that, however, still isn’t enough for bitcoin to actually succeed and live up to its potential. What can loosely be described as “social factors” (and of course luck!) are in my opinion much more determinative of success than the correctness of the concepts or the skill of implementation. Those things have to be right to create the possibility of success (defined as long-term preservation of value and ability to transact in bitcoins for a wide variety of goods and services), but are not sufficient. The high ambition of bitcoin creates a lot of hurdles to jump over that most projects don’t face. Satoshi has guts! As do other people who invest substantial effort and resources in building the bitcoin community, I remain very impressed by what already exists and has been accomplished.
I definitely believe bitcoin has the potential to deliver a “better user experience” of money than traditional systems, but at this point in time I don’t think the chicken-and-egg problem of creating adequate diversity of goods/services and ease of transaction in bitcoins without a large user community and vice versa has been accomplished. I will try to offer my best practical suggestion: someone should develop a very easy to deploy “pay with bitcoins!” web widget for people selling services over the web. The kind of small startups funded by ycombinator might be interested in innovative payment systems and they are often at a stage where revenues are so small that even minor paths to monetization would interest them. I don’t know exactly how you architect an ultra easy to use (for both service providers and consumers) bitcoin payment button, but I see it as something that could really drive adoption.
Related entries (1)
Related entries
This is great news with regard to mybitcoin’s merchant services! I think that will go a long way towards fueling adoption in the long run.
I still think, however, that the thing keeping bitcoin from taking off (virally) is that there is no specific use-value for bitcoin that only bitcoin can do best. It got me thinking, there is something that bitcoin has been used for all a long that we haven’t actually set up beyond the forum. Payment for good information! People have been putting bitcoin addresses in their forum signatures for a long time, and good, helpful posts seem to be rewarded at last to some extent.
My strategy is not to find specific niches that would work for bitcoin really well but to create lot of mini sites for bitcoins. It can’t hurt to have lot of miniservices by which users can spend their money on. This of course, contribute attraction for developers who might develop the right application that will be the viral niches that allow bitcoins to take off. Think of my strategy as a metastrategy for allowing your strategy to be viable.
Maybe I’m not understanding this completely, but it sounds vaguely to me that the suggestion is to use a ‘rabid libertarian’ tool to facilitate violation of intellectual property rights.
Intellectual property right violate real property right.
I’m not yet sold on the against-IP argument yet. I understand the scarce vs. non-scarce goods anti-IP argument that many libertarians are taking these days, but IMO it fails as soon as you say it voids private contracts. Disallowing individuals to enter into private contracts is obviously immoral, and yet some libertarians are arguing exactly that when they argue against IP. What’s wrong with me selling you a reproducible good with a contract attached that says you agree not to duplicate it? If you do, it’s dishonest and you’ve violated our contract.
The libertarians that I talk to know and accept this argument. So you’re arguing against quite possibly a strawman. What we’re against is involving third parties who have nothing to do with the non-copying agreement.
But my point is quite broad really, which is basically that people should look to voluntary solutions rather than everyone lining up at the government’s door to enact new laws. Getting stuck in the pro-IP/anti-IP legal debate is a very, very statist mindset, since it assumes that the government must either enforce for it or enforce against it — how about get the gov’t out of the way and let people figure it out! Some of the anti-IP crowd is even more statist than the pro-IP crowd: read about Sweden’s proposal to legalize piracy (thus voiding private contracts), tax all internet traffic and have the government decide how to hand out money to “content creators”…. that is frightening and insane IMO.
The Pirate Party is not what I consider to be “anti-IP” people, just “less copyright” people.
I’m not yet sold on the against-IP argument yet. I understand the scarce vs. non-scarce goods anti-IP argument that many libertarians are taking these days, but IMO it fails as soon as you say it voids private contracts. Disallowing individuals to enter into private contracts is obviously immoral, and yet some libertarians are arguing exactly that when they argue against IP. What’s wrong with me selling you a reproducible good with a contract attached that says you agree not to duplicate it? If you do, it’s dishonest and you’ve violated our contract.
Exactly. And such contracts could be structured in such a way as to have almost the same practical effect as IP enforcement. Which makes me suspect that arguments in favor of evading IP laws are as much about getting free music and free movies as they are about consistent libertarianism. But I’m still learning.
Not possible in libertarian theory. You can persecute the party in agreement with the contracts but third parties and outsider have no obligations.
The problem with evading IP laws to get free musics and movies is that they’re only promoting the monopolist’s interest, not the business interest of copyfree entrepreneurs.
Piracy[1] is a poor use of promoting free markets and libertarianism.
[1]: Piracy has apparently evolved into a catch-all phrase for “Things that Short-Sighted Commercial Dudes Don’t Want You To Do”. For our purpose, it means illegal copying of a monopolist’s pattern.
I’m not yet sold on the against-IP argument yet. I understand the scarce vs. non-scarce goods anti-IP argument that many libertarians are taking these days, but IMO it fails as soon as you say it voids private contracts. Disallowing individuals to enter into private contracts is obviously immoral, and yet some libertarians are arguing exactly that when they argue against IP. What’s wrong with me selling you a reproducible good with a contract attached that says you agree not to duplicate it? If you do, it’s dishonest and you’ve violated our contract.
Exactly. And such contracts could be structured in such a way as to have almost the same practical effect as IP enforcement. Which makes me suspect that arguments in favor of evading IP laws are as much about getting free music and free movies as they are about consistent libertarianism. But I’m still learning.
Not possible. You can persecute the party in agreement with the contracts but third parties and outsider have no obligations.
Sure, but you can make the penalties for violating the party in agreement so onerous that they would never get into the hands of third parties.
If they are willing to accept the agreement in the first place and the cost of enforcement does not exceed the profit from persecuting said violators. This is especially dubious when you have million of people with CDs. This is even more dubious if they can do it anonymously with no easy way to track the anonymous leak.
If people actually stop pirating in the said ideal world, than GIMP and other copyfree business will eat and run away with the copyright holder’s lunch.
if you make something artificially scarce, you better have the quality to make it worth people’s livelihood to host it at the movie theater.
So are the bitcoins in my wallet real property?
I supposed the thief owe you money after he spend it or destroy it.
Some actual businesses accepting bitcoins that sell physical goods would also go a long way toward helping them establish a foothold. I know there is one website selling herbs online, but the inventory there consists of only two things, so I assume this is a personal hobby endeavor and not an actual business.
Business beget business. Before you can have physical stores, you must do it with cheaper capital business.
One of the biggest (unknown?) enemies of OSS is piracy…
Great arguments as well for how piracy actually helps proprietary software
This is why I do the evil laugh when Short-Sighted Commercial Dude do something stupid like stopping piracy of their software.
So are the bitcoins in my wallet real property?
I supposed the thief owe you money after he spend it or destroy it.
But how can he ‘destroy’ my bitcoins? How are bitcoins ‘real’ property anymore than the music on a Celine Dion CD? That’s what I don’t understand. Aren’t bitcoins ‘artifically’ scarce?
By deleting your wallet, of course. It’s like deleting your Celine Dion mp3. That’s a destruction of property. You can alway download another one from the internet though. However, if you don’t back up your wallet, you lose it forever.
Well, I don’t know how to decide bitcoins. I mean, bitcoin can only be spent once and you can only discover a bitcoin. So if the thief spend your bitcoins, it mean that your bitcoin in your wallet are invalid. It doesn’t matter how many time you duplicate the bitcoin.
So are the bitcoins in my wallet real property?
Incidentally, there is nothing in your wallet that could be contrude as a coin. The use of the term, “wallet” to describe that file is a misnomer, as it contains only hash pairs and some transaction data. Your bitcoins are nothing more than a collection of transfers recorded in a massive ledger that we call the blockchain.
A convenient metaphor from the age of physical money. Let leave it at that.
I didn’t mean brick and mortar businesses. I just meant online businesses with a reasonably wide inventory. Selling things that a reasonably wide section of the population want to buy.
Well, I mean store that sell physical items, not brick and mortar businesses. In my sleep deprivation I slipped up.
And what if XYZ does violate the contract? How harsh would the penalties be in absence of a government-sponsored MPAA racket? Yeah, you could draft a contract that said “if you leak the film you owe me $100 million compensation”, but good luck finding a theatre chain who would be prepared to take that kind of risk. On the other hand, if the mutually agreed penalty was more market-realistic, say $1 million, that would no longer serve as deterrent onerous enough to prevent a leak. All it takes is 1 out of 10,000 employees being careless, or dishonest, and the damage is irreversible. XYZ would not bother investing millions in airport-style security scans for every cleaning lady that enters the cinema building. It would simply accept the risk of paying the penalty.
Right, so there is a point in your example somewhere between $1 million and $100 million where the theatre owner and the film producer can come to agreement. Some point where it is feasible to take the movie and risk it getting out in the world and duplicated for free, and some point where the theatre operator can make money showing the movie even if he has to pay the fine.
Theaters would just show public domain equalivent and be done with it. Smaller risk, and smaller profit maybe. Heck, public domain books these days sell, sometime like hotcake.
If somebody can make a million dollars worth of movie quality, and don’t force you to sign a non-copying agreement you’re basically screwed.
What can we do more and faster???
In a prosperous economy, everyone narrowly specialize and consume diversely.
Not everybody have a niche in the bitcoin economy, so there are no diverse consumption.
This forum could be used as support group for entrepreneurial activities and niche finding effort.
Good discussion above.
I want to come back to the original question about HOW TO DRIVE CRITICAL MASS.
Some people have express their belief that we should wait a couple of months before trying to make it bigger, but still think we should build on the momentum BITCOIN has currently. For example, bitcoin transactions, prices and turnover of coins have started to increase significantly over the past days. If we wait to long, it may die.
I also agree that we need to look for ways to have BITCOINS used in the right target group, i.e. Gaming, online shopping, etc.
What can we do more and faster???
One small thing that could be done right now by everyone is:
Install this Facebook game
http://www.facebook.com/#!/apps/application.php?id=157118501301&ref=tswhich is also listed in the bitcoin.org trade directoryhttp://www.bitcoin.org/trade. The game accepts bitcoins in payment. Invite 10 different Facebook friends to install the game everyday for a week.Its free, fast and takes almost no effort. And who knows, it may go viral and all of a sudden everyone will be asking ‘what are these bitcoins?’
Just be warned, I found the game addictive.
When you beat the game, it made a post at your blog bragging how good you are. Just by playing sweepmine, you help promote bitcoin and the game at the same time.
I don’t know what you mean by ‘go backward’. Do you mean after you have uncovered a square? No, once the mine goes off you’re done.
No sorry, I mean trade points on the game back to BTC.
No, I don’t think so. That would be a violation of Facebook TOS as I understand it.
This is simply another place to spend your BTC, and a pretty effective implementation he’s done too. If only we could get all app developers to do it.
The developer behind this project has done well. Now we will need to reciprocate by making something that he might want to spend bitcoin on. Fostering trade relations and interdependence is very important for a successful bitcoin economy.
