Couldn’t you describe many early-stage self-funded startups that way?
Self-funded startups that also involve major technical and conceptual advances that weren’t first developed in academia, government, or industry (and then spun off) seem rare. Can you give some examples that are similar to Bitcoin in this regard?
CarlShulmanOr do you mean you guess that Satoshi was not working in academia, government, or industry before developing Bitcoin?
If Satoshi was working in academia, government, or industry, it seems very likely that he didn’t develop the ideas behind Bitcoin as part of his day job, otherwise he probably wouldn’t have been allowed to publish the ideas and software under a pseudonym.
CarlShulmanSo getting a version of PayPal or Craigslist working somewhat earlier or better could easily affect more transactions and generate more consumer surplus if Bitcoin does not grow to larger scales.
It’s hard to even say whether Bitcoin ultimately has a positive or negative impact at this point. For example one possible impact of Bitcoin might be that due to its deficient monetary policy and associated price volatility it can’t grow to very large scales, and by taking over the cryptocurrency niche, it has precluded a future where a cryptocurrency does grow to very large scales. If we take the expectation of the absolute value of its impact, it seems higher to me than the impact of a somewhat earlier or better PayPal or Craigslist.

