BitBucks - a discussion starter
Suppose I wanted to create a system like bitcoin, but I wanted it to have a value pegged to the dollar. Let’s call it bitbuck. By definition, one bitbuck (BTB) would always trade at one USD.
In bitbuck’s case “like bitcoin” means that it does all the accounting and verification a la bitcoin. But it DOES NOT generate new coins with each block. Instead, an int max account is created in the first block belonging to the “Central BTB Reserve”. A centralized service would take care of moving BTB in and out of circulation.
It is easy to see that a central bank could work if it operated in the following fashion.
- The central bank would sell BTB in exchange for paper federal reserve notes.
- The central bank would alway deposit the paper in a safe “piggy bank”. (100% reserve on-demand access)
- The central bank would buy BTB on-demand in exchange for the FRN in the piggy bank.
That makes in a simplified version of PayPal. Except one with zero potential for profit. However, that also makes it a money transfer service with all the hassles that come from that.
But the key feature is people understand dollars. Both working for dollars and spending dollars for things priced in dollars. There is no extra “philosophy” to cloud acceptance. There are no exchange rates to check when comparing prices.
So that’s obvious and uninteresting, so far. But the real discussion I want to have is:
What if in the above scenario, you replaced “piggy bank” with a bitcoin wallet.
So to be clear, someone buys a bitbuck and the dollar is used ASAP on one of the existing exchanges to buy the equivalent quantity of bitcoin at market rates. These coins are held in the central banks bitcoin wallet, which is just like any other bitcoin user’s wallet. There is no special relationship between the two systems.
The benefit is that any merchant willing to accept bitcoins, automatically takes bitbucks as well. Since they probably already post an equivalent price in USD, they already have bitbuck prices listed. (There are pricing issues worth discussing.)
There is potential for the central bank to profit in USD if the value of BTC rises over time. There is a potential for loss if the value of BTC drops.
So in reality the bitbuck system wins by making bitcoin popular and loses if bitcoin fails to gain acceptance. (The risks here are worth discussing. And the likely necessity of a futures market for mitigating the risk.)
Related entries (1)
Related entries
And it seems to be centralized.
Now if I convert $10 to BTC, send it, and Y converts it to $11 he’s happy and I don’t care. But if he converts it to $9.50 he’s going to be a little annoyed. I don’t want that to happen because this is not a dual, it’s mutual cooperation.
Believe it or not there are lots of people who think like me.
What Y does with his money shouldn’t be your problem.
If it really has to be, then just pay him 220, or 250 or 400 or however much will mean you never feel guilty about getting a good deal.
I’m, probably too much of a sociopath to understand all this.
