Bitcoin Institute

Letter to the EFF

63 messages BitcoinTalk kiba, Bruce Wagner August 13, 2010 — November 16, 2010
kiba August 13, 2010 14:55 UTC Link to this message

Time to write a letter. Feel free to write your own paragraphs and the like, as well give feed back.

Dear EFF, the bitcoin community would like to donate X bitcoins, which are worth X USD because of the work EFF to protect new and emerging technologies, as well internet freedom. Bitcoin is a new emerging P2P cryptocurrency that have over 30 enterprises and a boatload of community members around the world. It have extremely low transaction cost, is hard to produce, and is hard to fake and as well many other property that make bitcoin a good money. As such it is probable that it will become a threat to centralized monetary system, whom are often backed by the state. Members of the bitcoin community as recognized this as a potential hazard impeding bitcoin adoption in addition to the threat of monetary freedom. We also recognized previously that you protect other kind of internet freedom, such as net neutrality. Thus, our motivation to donate to the EFF.

As, such, there are X unconditional donations, but there are X amount that have specific requirement for you to satisify. Conditions include the EFF setup a node and donation buttons for members of the bitcoin community to be able to donate. Others require you to mention bitcoin to help promote the cryptocurrency.

Of course, EFF can convert bitcoins to dollars at will, or buy goods and services with bitcoins, or simply do nothing with it at all. We, members of the bitcoin community hope that the EFF will put the donation to good use.

kiba August 13, 2010 16:45 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: silverman on August 13, 2010, 4:12:14 PM UTC

I would like to use simple, direct language that transmits one message — our support for EFF’s agenda. If we are at all effective as a medium of exchange, they will naturally discover the rest of our story. Three short paragraphs, maximum:

  1. Greetings: We appreciate your service to the community.

  2. Who we are: Peer-to-peer network based digital currency.

  3. How we can help: By donating xxx Bitcoins.

Sure, it is important to collect and discuss here the many things we will want to say, but let’s please keep the final message brief and to the point.

Very well: I follow your format.

Dear EFF, the bitcoin community appreciate your ongoing effort to protect internet freedom such as internet netruality and patent busting projects. We also see you an important partner to ensure that the bitcoin community goes unmolested or at least won’t go down without a fight.

The bitcoin community is a society of users with over 30 business enterprises based around a new open source P2P cryptocurrency and monetary system called bitcoins. The software for bitcoin is published under the MIT license. It have extremely low transaction cost, is hard to produce, and is hard to fake and as well many other property that make bitcoin a good money. As such it is probable that it will become a threat to centralized monetary system, whom are often backed by governments. Members of the bitcoin community recognized government’s interest in keeping their monetary monopoly and their resultant actions as possible threat to the growing bitcoin economy.

As, such, members of the bitcoin community would like to donate our goods, the cryptocurrency bitcoins to you. Members of the community will donate X bitcoins unconditionally, worth about X USD. We will also donate more if you fulfill various wishes such as putting up a bitcoin donation button, setting up a node and more. All together combined are X bitcoins, which are worth in total, X USD.

The EFF is free to convert bitcoins to other currencies at will, or buy goods and services with bitcoins, or simply do nothing with it at all. We, members of the bitcoin community hope that the EFF will put the donation to good use.

kiba August 13, 2010 17:48 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: hugolp on August 13, 2010, 5:43:39 PM UTC

Kiba, you forgot to mention that the bitcoin software is open source and GPL. Since we are writing to the EFF I think its important to specify it.

Edited the last letter to reflect this.

It’s actually licensed under the MIT. So I made use of the spirit of your suggestion instead.

kiba August 13, 2010 18:08 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: hugolp on August 13, 2010, 6:03:02 PM UTC

Edited the last letter to reflect this.

It’s actually licensed under the MIT. So I made use of the spirit of your suggestion instead.

No GPL? Unforgivable!!! I am leaving this community at once…  🙄

MIT is considered an open source license by the EFF, right?

Well, OSI and FSF would consider it open source.

kiba August 13, 2010 21:49 UTC Link to this message

So, does anybody have any constructive criticism for my letter? I found that I always write bad grammar and spell poorly.

kiba August 14, 2010 12:04 UTC Link to this message

Upgrade complete:

Dear EFF, the Bitcoin community appreciates your ongoing efforts to protect Internet freedom. We also see you as an important partner to ensure that the Bitcoin community goes unmolested or at least won’t go down without a fight.

The Bitcoin community is a society of users with over 30 business enterprises based around a new open source P2P cryptocurrency and monetary system called Bitcoins. The software for bitcoin is published under the MIT license. In addition to many other useful properties, Bitcoin has extremely low transaction fees, high divisibility, and is hard to produce and fake. These features make Bitcoin useful as a medium of exchange. As such it is probable that it will become a threat to centralized monetary system, which are often backed by governments. Members of the Bitcoin community have recognized the interest worldwide governments have in keeping their monetary monopoly. Their resulting actions could be a possible threat to the growing Bitcoin economy.

As such, members of the Bitcoin community would like to donate osome of our goods — cryptocurrency bitcoins — to you.. Members of the community will donate X bitcoins unconditionally, worth about X USD. We will also donate more if you fulfill various wishes such as putting up a bitcoin donation button, setting up a node and more. Combined, this is X Bitcoins, which are worth X USD in total.

The EFF is free to convert the Bitcoins to other currencies, buy goods and services with the Bitcoins, or simply do nothing with them at all. The members of the Bitcoin community hope that the EFF will put the donation to good use.

kiba August 15, 2010 01:30 UTC Link to this message

We also see you as an important partner to ensure that the Bitcoin community goes unmolested or at least won’t go down without a fight.

If you ever do expand to protecting alternative monetary system, the Bitcoin community have hopes that it will generally  be unmolested or at least won’t go down without a fight.

Reword complete. Good or not? Should I just delete this altogether?

kiba August 15, 2010 01:36 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: mizerydearia on August 15, 2010, 1:33:12 AM UTC

I think “unmolested” or any variant of “molested” is not so useful for wording

Well, its definition is:

not interfered with, disturbed, or harmed.

kiba August 15, 2010 03:00 UTC Link to this message

If you ever do expand to protecting alternative monetary system, the Bitcoin community have hopes that it will generally remains free of intervention.

Reword complete. RFC.

kiba August 15, 2010 06:29 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on August 15, 2010, 6:26:23 AM UTC

That is a truly awful sentence.

Saying how awful it is doesn’t exactly help me. The letter may not be that great, but it remains that I am the only one who is writing it.

kiba August 15, 2010 06:47 UTC Link to this message

The Bitcoin community hopes that it will generally remains free of intervention, weather or not if you ever expand to protecting alternative monetary system.

Reword complete. Request for comment.

kiba August 15, 2010 12:55 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on August 15, 2010, 6:52:21 AM UTC

The Bitcoin community hopes that it will generally remain free of intervention, perhaps with your support in the future.

Or even better:

The Bitcoin community hopes to generally remain free of intervention, perhaps with your support in the future.

Rewording accepted.

kiba August 15, 2010 13:59 UTC Link to this message

Upgrade complete. Request for comment.

Dear EFF, the Bitcoin community appreciates your ongoing efforts to protect Internet freedom. The Bitcoin community hopes to generally remain free of intervention, perhaps with your support in the future.

The Bitcoin community is a society of users with over 30 business enterprises based around a new open source P2P cryptocurrency and monetary system called Bitcoins. The software for bitcoin is published under the MIT license. In addition to many other useful properties, Bitcoin has extremely low transaction fees, high divisibility, and is hard to produce and fake. These features make Bitcoin useful as a medium of exchange. As such it is probable that it will become a threat to centralized monetary system, which are often backed by governments. Members of the Bitcoin community have recognized the interest worldwide governments have in keeping their monetary monopoly. Their resulting actions could be a possible threat to the growing Bitcoin economy.

As such, members of the Bitcoin community would like to donate osome of our goods — cryptocurrency bitcoins — to you. Members of the community will donate X bitcoins unconditionally, worth about X USD. We will also donate more if you fulfill various wishes such as putting up a bitcoin donation button, setting up a node and more. Combined, this is X Bitcoins, which are worth X USD in total.

The EFF is free to convert the Bitcoins to other currencies, buy goods and services with the Bitcoins, or simply do nothing with them at all. The members of the Bitcoin community hope that the EFF will put the donation to good use.

kiba August 15, 2010 23:57 UTC Link to this message

I think the donations are one-time only. Nobody has pledged to donate per monthly.

kiba August 16, 2010 02:11 UTC Link to this message

I took Ichi’s version and modified it a little bit.

Dear Electronic Fronter Foundation, the Bitcoin community appreciates your ongoing efforts to protect Internet freedom. We hope to generally remain free of intervention, and would welcome your support.

The Bitcoin community comprises approximately N users and over 30 business enterprises employing a new open-source P2P cryptocurrency and monetary system called Bitcoins. The software for bitcoin is published under the MIT license. In addition to many other useful properties, Bitcoin has extremely low transaction fees, high divisibility, and is hard to produce and fake. These features make Bitcoin useful as a medium of exchange. As such, Bitcoin may become a threat to centralized monetary systems, which are typically backed by governments. The Bitcoin community knows that governments will defend their monetary monopolies, perhaps by suppressing the Bitcoin economy.

As a demonstration of our value, members of the Bitcoin community would like to donate some of our goods — cryptocurrency bitcoins — to you. In order to facilitate that process, we request that you add a bitcoin donation button to the EFF website.  That would involve setting up a Bitcoin node, which is quite straightforward. We estimate that EFF would receive approximately X bitcoins currently worth about Y USD. We note that, by accepting bitcoin donations, EFF might expand its support base (perhaps substantially).

kiba August 16, 2010 04:56 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 16, 2010, 4:30:38 AM UTC

The Bitcoin community appreciates … [rest of body]

I think it just sound better to greet the Electronic Frontier Foundation. Beside, the starter sentence feel “out of the blue”.

kiba August 17, 2010 00:16 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: The MadHatter on August 16, 2010, 7:24:29 AM UTC

A super geeky way to do subscription payments is with the console client and cron. 😛

If the EFF had a Bitcoin address I’d donate often.

Only to forget! Your client need a regular donation mechanism.

kiba August 17, 2010 15:52 UTC Link to this message

Letter upgrade, complete.

Dear Electronic Fronter Foundation,

The Bitcoin community appreciates your ongoing efforts to protect Internet freedom. We hope to remain free of intervention and would welcome your support

The Bitcoin community comprises approximately N users and over 30 business enterprises employing a new open-source P2P cryptocurrency and monetary system called Bitcoins. The software for bitcoin is published under the MIT license. In addition to many other useful properties, Bitcoin has extremely low transaction fees, high divisibility, and is difficult to produce and counterfeit. These features make Bitcoin useful as a medium of exchange. As such, Bitcoin may become a threat to centralized monetary systems, which are typically backed by governments. The Bitcoin community knows that governments will defend their monetary monopolies, perhaps by suppressing the Bitcoin economy.

Members of the Bitcoin community have expressed an interest in donating [cryptocurrency] bitcoins to you as a gesture of appreciation. In order to facilitate that process, we request that you add a bitcoin donation button to the EFF website.  That would involve setting up a Bitcoin node, which is quite straightforward. We estimate that EFF would receive approximately X bitcoins currently worth about Y USD. We note that, by accepting bitcoin donations, EFF might expand its support base (perhaps substantially).

kiba August 17, 2010 19:55 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 17, 2010, 7:45:49 PM UTC

Thanks, kiba  😊

FWIW, I support dropping “cryptocurrency”.  Bitcoin is what it is, and that’s well-described elsewhere.

So, what are the current best estimates for N, X and Y?

We have about 575 bitcoins, which translate to 37.72 dollars at the current exchange rate of 0.056.

Not everybody pledged a donation. Some of which probably won’t be donated at all.

kiba August 17, 2010 20:01 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 17, 2010, 7:59:17 PM UTC

Are those pledges, or in an account?  I vaguely remember another thread.  Help?

How may Bitcoin clients are there currently?

http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=778.0

kiba August 17, 2010 20:08 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 17, 2010, 8:07:01 PM UTC

Thanks.  I pledged.

In this thread (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=846.msg9952;topicseen#msg9952), lfm writes that “I see about 850 connections to the IRC channel.”  Is that our best estimate?

That’s quite an assumption. It would mean there are 1 user for each nodes. It is more probable than some users run more nodes than other.

kiba August 17, 2010 20:17 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 17, 2010, 8:14:04 PM UTC

OK, just say 850 nodes, then.  Could we assume that all members of this forum are users?  What’s that number?  And would exchanges report numbers of distinct clients?

We have 691 users, with 9818 posts. This is about 36 posts a day, 3 members a day, and 15 users online each day.

kiba August 20, 2010 12:55 UTC Link to this message

So, is the letter all right or I am missing some criticism?

kiba August 20, 2010 14:46 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: fresno on August 20, 2010, 2:20:36 PM UTC

I think the term “cryptocurrency” will come back to bite us someday, but Satoshi has already used it publicly, it is a coined word with no prior usage, and it works.

Trying to get the community to use words other than what accurately describe bitcoin is a losing proposition.

kiba August 20, 2010 19:39 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: ichi on August 20, 2010, 7:25:53 PM UTC

I like the version of the letter that you posted, fresno.  It says all that’s necessary.  I have a few minor edits.

Oh yeah, the letter…

Dear Electronic Frontier Foundation,

The Bitcoin community appreciates your efforts protecting Internet freedom, and keeping the Internet free of unneeded regulatory intervention.

Today’s Bitcoin community comprises approximately N enterprises and indiviuals, using a new open-source P2P cryptocurrency system called Bitcoins https://bitcoin.org that is published under the MIT license.

Several members of our community have asked to donate Bitcoins to your Foundation, with xxx Bitcoins being pledged so far. We are certain that you will receive many more in individual donations if you will set up an EFF Bitcoin node.

Warmest regards,

The Bitcoin Community.

I think the term “cryptocurrency” will come back to bite us someday, but Satoshi has already used it publicly, it is a coined word with no prior usage, and it works.

Satoshi may have coined “cryptocurrency”, and “crypto currency” has been in use for decades.

I am happy to accept Fresco’s version since others like it.

kiba August 24, 2010 19:18 UTC Link to this message

Is the letter ready to send to EFF?

kiba August 27, 2010 15:35 UTC Link to this message

So…where do I send the letter to?

kiba August 28, 2010 16:15 UTC Link to this message

Dear Electronic Frontier Foundation,

The Bitcoin community appreciates your efforts to protect freedom and to keep the Internet free of unnecessary regulatory intervention.

 Bitcoin https://bitcoin.org is a new open-source P2P cryptocurrency system, published under the MIT license.

There are several enterprises and individuals in the Bitcoin community. Many have expressed their desire to donate to your foundation, with 800 Bitcoins pledged to date.

We are certain that you will receive many more in individual donations if you will set up your own EFF Bitcoin node.

Warmest regards, The Bitcoin community

I sent this letter with “several” not “several hundred” to the EFF. I don’t like to exaggerate.

kiba August 31, 2010 01:45 UTC Link to this message

At this time, I still do not have anything from the EFF.

kiba September 4, 2010 20:38 UTC Link to this message

Nothingness and Nothingness.  😕

kiba September 8, 2010 04:25 UTC Link to this message

No reply, ever. Any suggestion on how I should move next?

kiba September 12, 2010 05:38 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on September 09, 2010, 4:14:11 AM UTC

I might be able to help with this. I have a personal contact with one of the guys who founded EFF. I will write him a letter. No promises though.

Any progress for that matter?

kiba September 12, 2010 16:59 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: gumtree on September 12, 2010, 12:44:20 PM UTC

Probably just by sending everybody’s Bitcoin commodity donations to the “eff” via Bitcoinmail to: membership at eff dot org  … will introduce them to Bitcoins when they claim the donation (having to actually download the Bitcoin client app to receive the donation - and sell the Bitcoins for national currency - through one of the Bitcoin commodity exchanges if national currency might still be needed by them to conduct business in the conventional economy - alternatively they could embrace Bitcoin commodity and use Bitcoin commodity, as payment in like, if they can on there part again, reach agreement with their trading partners).  https://www.eff.org/about/contact

I have choosen to use mybitcoin, which are essential online bitcoin account. Very easy to use. I just need to give them the password and the username.

kiba September 13, 2010 20:53 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on September 13, 2010, 8:37:39 PM UTC

Also, Kiba, please go ahead and post some Bitcoin addresses here for the EFF MyBitcoin account so we can all donate to it.

Great news: The EFF is definitely interested in recieving Bitcoins!

It’s in another thread for EFF donations. I don’t have much time to do anything right now as I am in college.

Also, can you please post the email message from the EFF so we know what it says or does that violate social convention.

kiba September 14, 2010 03:43 UTC Link to this message

Done. Now all that’s left is to wait.

kiba September 14, 2010 03:51 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on September 14, 2010, 3:51:05 AM UTC

Done. Now all that’s left is to wait.

Sweet! Did you ask if they would post an address on their website for future bitcoin donations?

I haven’t asked this yet and don’t want to annoy if you already asked.

Nope. My email was simply about the mybitcoin account.

kiba September 16, 2010 00:46 UTC Link to this message

Have you heard anything back?

kiba September 18, 2010 22:13 UTC Link to this message

Anything yet?

kiba September 23, 2010 17:52 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: mizerydearia on September 19, 2010, 10:50:50 PM UTC

Pestering them about a Bitcoin button is not a good idea. It was a gift, not a bribe.

Just give them the Bitcoins and follow up in two weeks.

2 weeks 2,419,200 seconds Same amount of time as expected time to generate 2,016 blocks

How many days we have left?

kiba September 30, 2010 02:56 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on September 30, 2010, 1:59:39 AM UTC

Should I follow up with the EFF? What do I ask?

Indeed…what to do.

Unfortunately, I lack facilities in learning and discovering social norms.[1]


  1. That’s a bit of an exaggeration. Let just say that I have asperger syndrome and I am slow to catch on as far as the social game goes.
kiba October 1, 2010 01:44 UTC Link to this message

Perhaps the next step is to ask if they have access to the account or need help.

You could ask them if they would like to receive more bitcoin? Thus leading to the question if they will put up a donation box.

kiba October 1, 2010 04:42 UTC Link to this message

You should remove the account info for the bitcoin account as soon as possible.

kiba October 1, 2010 15:50 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on October 01, 2010, 10:04:28 AM UTC

. I’d say they rejected the donation. (Probably because they are busy eating and drinking with politicians.)

I am going to go with the optimistic hypothesis that they got bigger fish to fry than try to exchange bitcoins for paypal dollars.

With the famousness that they have with geeks, it wouldn’t be surprising that they simply forgot our email.

kiba October 1, 2010 20:41 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on October 01, 2010, 6:44:30 PM UTC

The fact is, if we don’t get a response within the next week … or 2 weeks at the most … I mean, at some point we need to follow up, right?

I just need to figure out what to ask.

Hi, did you managed to get control of the mybitcoin account?

kiba October 1, 2010 21:47 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on October 01, 2010, 9:02:45 PM UTC

. I’d say they rejected the donation. (Probably because they are busy eating and drinking with politicians.)

I am going to go with the optimistic hypothesis that they got bigger fish to fry than try to exchange bitcoins for paypal dollars.

With the famousness that they have with geeks, it wouldn’t be surprising that they simply forgot our email.

Even if no money was attached it is pretty lame for a company claiming to be fighting for freedom to not be interested in a money that can be used freely.

You mean, uh, charity.

kiba October 2, 2010 04:41 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BrightAnarchist on October 01, 2010, 11:22:47 PM UTC

The fact is, if we don’t get a response within the next week … or 2 weeks at the most … I mean, at some point we need to follow up, right?

I just need to figure out what to ask.

Hi, did you managed to get control of the mybitcoin account?

Makes sense. What do you say — wait 1 week and then ask?

Apparently I’m incapable of making an independent decision.

Have we not wait two weeks already?

kiba October 2, 2010 05:15 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Anonymous on October 02, 2010, 4:43:28 AM UTC

We could always pick another recipient. I vote for Stephan Molyneux.

While he is not the eff he is the pre-eminent liberty philosopher of our time.

I would prefer not to waste the donations of everyone here in the community. The donation was already sent. At the very least, the EFF would liquidate the coins.

kiba October 2, 2010 05:19 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Anonymous on October 02, 2010, 4:43:28 AM UTC

We could always pick another recipient. I vote for Stephan Molyneux.

While he is not the eff he is the pre-eminent liberty philosopher of our time.

ESR might be willing to accept bitcoin donations.

He is both a hacker and anarchist and he would fit right in with the bitcoin community.

kiba October 2, 2010 20:30 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BioMike on October 02, 2010, 8:21:02 PM UTC
  1. Contact one of their sister organisations in other countries, asking if they are interested.

<edit>For point 2, mail the EFF with an ultimatum for the EFF to collect the coins.</edit>

Ultimatum? I don’t understand …

“If we don’t hear from you before <some_date> we assume that you are not interested in the donation and we will find an other organisation that might be more interested in this donation.”

Or something like that.

Well it’s kinda impossible at this point. I already hand them the mybitcoin account.

kiba October 4, 2010 16:20 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: silverman on October 04, 2010, 3:27:42 PM UTC

Know everything you can about your customers:

http://news.slashdot.org/story/10/10/04/1454231/Free-Software-Foundation-Turns-25

Stallman is less receptive than Raymond simply because Stallman is just a moderate socialist. Raymond is an anarchist and he’s already siting on the fence about IP abolishment.

Nonetheless, I don’t know if the free software crowd would be receptive to bitcoin and ciphergeeks and anarchistic hackers that surround it.

kiba October 5, 2010 22:13 UTC Link to this message

No email from the EFF?  ❓

Maybe ya need to send a letter until it get noticed by the EFF people.

kiba October 6, 2010 19:50 UTC Link to this message

No email?  😢

kiba October 6, 2010 20:40 UTC Link to this message
kiba October 8, 2010 00:33 UTC Link to this message

Two months of work…success!

kiba October 8, 2010 02:57 UTC Link to this message

I guess this thread will be used for news of EFF’s eventual implementation of bitcoins.

kiba October 22, 2010 23:26 UTC Link to this message

So I don’t see any mentions to donating to bitcoins on EFF’s WAY TO HELP page?

kiba October 24, 2010 03:17 UTC Link to this message

Someone will need to commence asking EFF what is up.

kiba October 30, 2010 19:38 UTC Link to this message

Seem to me that nobody is willing to do the deed, I guess I’ll have to contact them.

kiba November 9, 2010 16:49 UTC Link to this message

Wow…just wow.

Thanks for everybody who help and donated the funds for EFF.

Bruce Wagner November 15, 2010 17:56 UTC Link to this message

All I can say is:     “kiba, Hero Member”

Oh, and…  I’m calling my media contacts at PC World and such…

We’ll see what happens.      😊

kiba November 16, 2010 05:43 UTC Link to this message

Thanks for the media storm created by jimbobaway.

kiba November 16, 2010 06:05 UTC Link to this message

And now I can claim that I started the longest thread on this forum, ever.

AND! I just extended it by one post longer with my declaration. 😄