Printing bitcoins : could it work?
It all comes down to how much you trust the entitiy you are transacting with.
If I’m paying the kid mowing my lawn in Bitcoin ‘notes’ I know I’m honest. If there is some problem we can sort it out when he comes back next month. If I’m buying my groceries from ‘Big Grocery Store’ (BGS) they will be doing online transaction processing to verify my Bitcoin notes are valid before I leave the store, and I can trust that the notes they are printing me for my change will be valid. If I’m borrowing 10BTC from my friend, he can pass a note from the BGS to me because I can trust he he’s not double spending it. The note can proceed down the chain of trust.
If I’m buying a DVD from a guy on a street corner, he might not be inclined to take my bitcoin note (unless he has an iPhone to check the transaction is valid) and I’ll probably want to use exact change, because I’m not going to trust any notes he gives me in return.
Bitcoin notes are a great solution when you are:
a) Offline b) Dealing with someone you trust.
It also doesn’t prevent you choosing to use some other method. It just provides you with an extra option. Which is a Good Thing.
All that is required is that you have an address of his.
If you mean Bitcoin address, you shouldn’t even need this.
CcreightoHe doesn’t need to verify that your money is good; he knows where you live and he couldn’t force you to pay him if you refused anyway. He is dependent upon your honesty from the start, although if you screw him, not only are you going to have to cut your own grass, you might wake up one day and find someone has salted your flowers.
Exactly.
I’d love to see printed bitcoins.
Basically, a bearer-bond note in a 2D barcode.
The receiver would have no protection against double-spend, so it would behoove them to scan it on-the-spot and get it into the Bitcoin network. They could wait for a confirmation, or not.
It seems like this would be pretty simple — get the client to generate a one-time receiving address, pay to it, and then print out the address public/private key pair onto the note. Any scanner would then have the required keys to receive the transaction and re-spend the coin.
Assuming the receiver has a method to scan & post the note, it’s no less secure than any other means of bitcoin payment, right?
Related entries (1)
Related entries
Personal checks, however, could potentially print the private key, but even that presents a risk that an employee of a company could steal the coins before the company could claim them.
Shops seem to do fine accepting dollar bills which are subject to the same risk.
Um, no, they are not subject to the same risks. The US FRN is physically the object of value. With a bitcoin backed note, the paper note is simply data. If the private key is on the note, that data can be used to take the value of the note without needing to take the note itself. If we were to make a paper note that had the private keys, it wouldn’t be long before some employee was stealing bitcoins from their employer by taking photos of the notes and using the keys to transfer the bitcoins before the company’s billing department could do so.
You have an interesting idea of what value is.
It doesn’t matter if there is a piece of paper there or not. Either way, the billing department is going to start asking questions and firing (or worse) the guilty parties.
Maybe I’m dense, but I still don’t get it. The whole point in handling paper bitcoins is to do so without a central “issuing authority”. I want to print my own, and accept them from anyone’s home printer.
I totally understand that “showing your bills” to someone gives them a chance to photograph, and “receive them” (steal them, intercept, cash in, whatever).
That’s just part of the deal. You’re carrying machine-readable (2d barcode) bearer-coins. Show them only to the party you are paying, who is expected to transfer them on-the-spot to another account.
The receiver needs a network connection, the payer does not. Perfect for customer/merchant scenarios.
You seem pretty certain about it, creighto. I’m not trying to change your mind, and if I and a merchant can find a system that works for “handing over” physical Bitcoins, I suppose it doesn’t have to involve anyone else.
As a thought experiment, imagine the “scratch off” lottery tickets. You can’t see the receiving key until you scratch it, which makes it visibly void. A drawer full of these ought to alert the shift manager than an employee isn’t following SOP. 😊
I don’t really get the difference betwen “checks” and printed coins, except that a check sounds like it involves an intermediate processor — a cashing authority or bank. No can do. The whole point is anonymous payer, anonymous receiver. I don’t want to know who cashed the check, and I don’t want them knowing who wrote it.
If I’m willing to divulge everything, might as well have a Bank Of Bitcoin MasterCard and leave it at that.
Scratch-offs are an amazing idea.
Or you could just fold it over and staple it.
as in the ‘neighbor kid moans the lawn’ scenario
Your neighborhood sounds pretty fun. 😲 [Editor: “moans” in the quoted post is a slip for “mows.”]
Is it possible that ‘testing’ a bitcoin bill for double-spend could be done much faster than confirmation?
After all, you just want to know if the coin has been previously spent.
SO the cashier takes the bill with the 2D barcode, scans it, and the register confirms that the coin hasn’t been previously spent (ie, the balance is real). The confirmations can come later if the merchant wants to extend some trust. Seems this wouldn’t take any longer than a Visa authorization.
In a nutshell, my goal is to pay for something
- Anonymously (thank you sir, you have no idea who I am.)
- Spontaneously (I wasn’t planning to spend bills at lunch, but here I am)
- Off-line (I didn’t bring my gadgets)
- Minimal trust required (Give me physical goods, and you have reasonable confidence my bill is good.)
A completely separate discussion would be valid for discussing a quick way to share BTC addresses, IRL. Cut & Paste works fine. “Read your number to me” would not. A standard 2D sticker on the back of a register would be the ticket here. “BTC Accepted @” with a phone client that scans and pays.
