Bitcoin Institute

Why I am not concerned about the ethics of miner botnets.

2 messages BitcoinTalk chickenado November 27, 2011 — November 29, 2011
chickenado November 27, 2011 21:48 UTC Link to this message

I just had a look at Litecoin project, and I was perplexed that its susceptibility to botnet mining was listed as a “disadvantage”.

I see botnet operators as petty criminals who have managed to find a large number of victims.

  1. Most of their victims don’t even realize that they are victims.
  2. The damage per victim is small (a few extra dollars a month in electricity bills)
  3. A clever botnet operator doesn’t get greedy and causes as little disruption as possible to his victims.  The “market” weeds out the ones who get too aggressive and only the stealthy ones survive long term.  The guys who start stealing CC numbers in addition to mining will inevitably attract attention from their victims.  The “nice” botnet operators, on the other hand, can continue mining for months without being discovered.
  4. It’s not in the interest of a botnet operator to do a 51% attack because that will make his booty worthless.  Unless he gets paid by someone whose aim it is to destroy bitcoin. But that someone could just do the 51% attack himself without going through a middleman.

Sure, botnets are a “disadvantage” for the victims, but not for the cryptocoin itself.

Should it bother me that a part of the bitcoin network is being secured by criminals, and that when I buy freshly minted coins, some of them come from criminals? Perhaps.

Here is the thing though:

Almost everybody I know buys their fossil fuels from criminals, without even giving it a second thought.  And we are talking about real criminals here, people who commit mass murder and torture, not some nihilistic geek living in his parents’ basement who causes a barely noticeable inconvenience for a few million people.

This is why I don’t understand all this moral outrage about miner botnets. First things first, surely?

chickenado November 29, 2011 09:50 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: BTCurious on November 29, 2011, 9:35:20 AM UTC

The safest would be a proof-of-work that requires both GPU and CPU.

I hardly think that computers with a decent GPU don’t have a decent CPU, so this wouldn’t improve anything. Only exception is these GPU-Supercomputers, but they won’t be included in botnets.

Depends how it’s done.  Instead of perfoming SHA256 and Scrypt in series, you could use just SHA256 for even blocks and just Scrypt for odd blocks.

This would ensure that ordinary users still get a chance at defending the chain, while making it hard for CPU botnets.