Bitcoin Institute

Bitcoin Threat Model

5 messages BitcoinTalk kiba December 5, 2010 — December 5, 2010
kiba December 5, 2010 01:32 UTC Link to this message

Please note, this is a revised version of an email that I sent to a guy who know something about security.


1. Who are our adversaries?

Corporations who have their business destroyed by bitcoin competition, or in the process of getting destroyed. Government who are keen to control their economy through central banking.

2. What are their capabilities?

Security and cryptanalysis knowledge. Nation-state level resources. Ability to use force and threats to keep people in line.

3. What are our countermeasure?

Network effect; strength in number. Promoting, and growing the economy.

Security and cryptanalysis knowledge. Constant discussion about security.

Decentralization effort such as BitDNS. I open sourced my prediction market; however, we do not have open source exchange markets and other critical infrastructure.

The head cannot be easily cut off. The authority will find it difficult to haul away Satoshi Nakamoto, but it cannot be said the same for other people. Already growing the number of hacker who know how bitcoin work and can improve it.

4. Measures we could take:

Create a dedicated tiger team whom jobs is to find security flaws within the network.

Offer security bounties as incentives.

Open source key infrastructure such as trading sites.

Create protocol documentation.

“Kill switch” for bitcoin banks system. (Really, it mean that everyone who hold bitcoin balance on the behalf of somebody else.)

kiba December 5, 2010 03:21 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on December 05, 2010, 3:17:58 AM UTC

This is not reality. If government could enforce laws there would be no drugs, no murder, no theft. These things plainly exist. Government cannot enforce law, but only uses it as a pretense to capture adversaries and control those who produce for them. This may be important when considering security. Also there is no monolithic government, but only individuals who are acting in their interests or out of fear.

Updated my analysis.

kiba December 5, 2010 04:37 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: em3rgentOrdr on December 05, 2010, 3:46:16 AM UTC

great analysis kiba!  Thanks for starting this discussion.  Bounties for exposing security vulnerabilities is an excellent and very creative idea!  Where do I pledge or send bitcoins to?  How will the review committee that evaluates any claimed vulnerabilities be structured/governed?  How to ensure that coders who contribute changes to bitcoin source code don’t secretly deliberately include faulty obfuscated code so that they can fix their broken code to collect the bounty (or avoid similar other conflicts of interests)?

Err, just start a bounty thread?

kiba December 5, 2010 04:52 UTC Link to this message

Bold the heading, incorporated one of RHorning’s suggestion.

kiba December 5, 2010 18:44 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: RHorning on December 05, 2010, 6:35:33 PM UTC

There are counter measures, but if you get involved in some of these exchanges, you should be aware of the potential risks.  If you have a claim to those coins through the Bitcoin network, this isn’t a risk at all at least along those lines and the coins are as safe as the network as a whole.

I incoprorated your excellent countermeasure suggestion.