Bitcoin Institute

Money as Debt

14 messages BitcoinTalk Bruce Wagner, kiba November 28, 2010 — January 10, 2011
Bruce Wagner November 28, 2010 22:46 UTC Link to this message

Do you guys agree with “the facts” as presented in this film, Money As Debt http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2550156453790090544

Bruce Wagner November 28, 2010 23:51 UTC Link to this message

No no.  It seems true to me.   I first saw this film quite a while ago - long before I discovered bitcoin.  That’s why I was curious if this is in alignment with the world view of people here, or not.   Does anyone disagree with anything presented there? Only one issue I have trouble understanding / believing:  Toward the end he describes a theoretical new money system (bitcoin??) with a limited finite number of units.  He says that, within such as system, if lenders were allowed to lend money and charge interest on loans… eventually the lenders would end up with all the money.  I have trouble believing that.  The money holds no real value except when it is spent.  It seems like the rich “lenders” would spend their money,  sooner or later. And even if they didn’t - at least in the case of bitcoin - however small the number of bitcoins in circulation,  they can always be subdivided into smaller and smaller units (i. e. 0.0000000001 BTN )

kiba November 29, 2010 01:00 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: bober182 on November 29, 2010, 12:56:23 AM UTC

I’m a bit more then just a socialist and I know bitcoin is a step towards getting away from government/corporation authority and control. After that it will help move into a classless society and possibly money will be abolished altogether.

And there will be still rich bitcoiners and poor bitcoiners.

Bruce Wagner November 29, 2010 02:23 UTC Link to this message

Woah!  I just watched the sequel…  Money As Debt II   ( here: http://vimeo.com/6822294 )

Is it my imagination or are they totally describing Bitcoin toward the end…!?!?

This sequel was done in 2009…?   Did they already know about Bitcoin then…?

It’s almost like they were forecasting the invention of Bitcoin…

We need to get the producers of THIS FILM to do an animated video describing Bitcoin!!!!

Bruce Wagner November 29, 2010 02:41 UTC Link to this message

Ok, I just wrote an email to the creators of the film…

To:  [e-mail address] Subject:  Money as Debt II

Hello!

We are discussing your film in the Bitcoin Forum  ( here http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1992.0 )

Are you already familiar with Bitcoin?!?!?

If not, please see  http://BitcoinMe.com for a quick introduction to what it’s all about.

Bitcoin is a FOSS (free open source software) project that is making huge advances very quickly.   The Bitcoin economy is already over US$1.3 Million in total value.

We already have a “bounty”  ( sort of a contest, to see who can come up with the best animated video explaining Bitcoin to everyday people… with the best video winning the prize pot… currently about $2,520 ).   See http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=697.0;all

I think it would be wonderful if you were to create a film explaining  “What is a Bitcoin?”       

Also, I’ve gotta ask…     Toward the end of “Money As Debt II”, you were describing a digital currency enabled through encryption technology…   Were you already aware, at that time, that Bitcoin existed… or was about to be invented?

Bruce Wagner New York City http://BitcoinMe.com xxx-xxx-xxxx

Why didn’t we think of contacting them before? By the way, when exactly did Bitcoin first launch - what date?   (I need to brush up on some of my basic facts before my national radio interview about Bitcoin on Thursday morning!)

kiba November 29, 2010 04:10 UTC Link to this message

Fractional reserve banking mean that the bank have a tendency to collapse. I think we’re safer with mtgox type banks where they just keep the balance and earn their fees somewhere.

Bruce Wagner December 1, 2010 08:20 UTC Link to this message

Just to follow-up…   That original email that I sent to the “Money as Debt” producers came back to me today, returned to sender.  Apparently, that email address was no good?

kiba December 1, 2010 14:24 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: creighto on December 01, 2010, 2:21:34 PM UTC

Read books, not websites.

Seriously? Like the information in “books” is any more “real” than “websites” </rant>

Maybe I’m too old, but I don’t know many economic websites.

http://www.mises.org

Bruce Wagner December 1, 2010 20:22 UTC Link to this message

Ok…  I got a reply today.   😊

To refresh your memory, I sent the following email to the creator of the film, “Money As Debt II”…

To: Paul Grignon <[e-mail address]>

Hello!

We are discussing your film in the Bitcoin Forum  ( here http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1992.0 )

Are you already familiar with Bitcoin?!?!?

If not, please see  http://BitcoinMe.com for a quick introduction to what it’s all about.

Bitcoin is a FOSS (free open source software) project that is making huge advances very quickly.   The Bitcoin economy is already over US$1.3 Million in total value.

We already have a “bounty”  ( sort of a contest, to see who can come up with the best animated video explaining Bitcoin to everyday people… with the best video winning the prize pot… currently about $2,520 ).   See http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=697.0;all

I think it would be wonderful if you were to create a film explaining “What is a Bitcoin?”

Also, I’ve gotta ask…     Toward the end of “Money As Debt II”, you were describing a digital currency enabled through encryption technology…   Were you already aware, at that time, that Bitcoin existed… or was about to be invented?

Bruce Wagner New York City http://BitcoinMe.com xxx-xxx-xxxx

Today, I received his reply…

Hi Bruce

No I did not know about bitcoin when I made Money as Debt II

It sounds like you didn’t watch to the end of the credits where I send you to digitalcoin.info

The idea came from the technology being developed at maidsafe.net.

The  inventors, having seen Money as Debt asked me for help explaining their technology. This is the animated movie I made for them (the 12 min. link)

 http://www.paulgrignon.netfirms.com/MoonfireStudio/PAGES/PD/Perpetual_Data_homepageFlash.html

They also asked me for ideas how to use it as a completely liberated money system.

Money as Debt II ends by sending the viewer to digitalcoin.info   which is my answer to their question.

I didn’t get paid for any of this by the way.  I am not working FOR them.

I was previously invited to enter this contest and declined.

Making it a contest is, from my viewpoint, highly disrespectful of the work it would take to do a good job.

But if someone does have the time to spare you may get what you want.

I am currently busy completing Money as Debt III, Evolution Beyond Money explaining my alternative economy concepts.

It will hopefully be as educationally useful and well-accepted as the first two movies.

By the way there are no “producers’.  Other than the narration I do everything.

Paul

First, I wanted to let Paul Grignon know that we meant no disrespect by calling it a “bounty” or a “contest”.

We all just want to honor those who create great works.  We have a desire to scrape together whatever coins we can, to say “Thank You” to those who create such fantastic works.  In fact, I propose that we stop calling these things “a bounty” or “a contest”.   We should call it  “an award”.   We have created “a new award”… “an award with a prize attached”.   Because that’s what it really is.  We can also express that “we are seeking nominations” for the award.   That sounds so much more respectful of all the hard work - blood, sweat, and tears - that software developers, film animators, and any other types of content-creators produce… and contribute for the benefit of us all.  The small “prize” we offer is not a purchase price.  It’s simply one token of our appreciation for their hard work.  It’s a Thank You.

Next, I want everyone here to look at Paul’s ideas.   They’re very interesting.   Don’t just skim over them.  Study them.  His concept of - what he calls “Digital Coin” - encompasses TWO TYPES of digital currency.  One Type, which he calls the “Perpetual Coin”, represents “permanent value” (that one sounds like an exact match to Bitcoin - correct me if I’m wrong?).  The Other Type, which he calls a “Credit Coin”, represents a form of a “value voucher” that anyone can issue themselves… and spend into circulation… in effect, giving themselves instant credit.  (For example, if I install Linux for people.  I can issue a “Bruce Wagner Consulting 20 BTC Credit Coin”.  That coin would be worth 20 BTC worth of my services/products, as they are priced whenever it is redeemed.)  However, he proposes that the actual value of the Credit Coins I issue would vary… based on real-time trading of these Credit Coins on automated markets (think http://MtGox.com).  If demand for my services/products was low, the value (the relative value, as measured in how many “real” BTC people are willing to buy/sell them for) of the “Bruce Wagner Consulting 20 BTC Credit Coins” I issued would be lower.  If demand for my services/products was high, the value (again, the relative value, as measured in how many “real” BTC people are willing to buy/sell them for) of the “Bruce Wagner Consulting 20 BTC Credit Coins” I issued, would be higher.  However, in any case, that Credit Coin would ultimately always be redeemable by ME (the issuer) at 20 BTC WORTH of my services/products (at MY current “real” BTC prices).   He also proposes that these Credit Coins would have a premium value if used (spent at Bruce Wagner Consulting) within a certain timeline (not immediately), and also that they would have a decreasing value over time… ultimately expiring completely.  Thus, “forcing them” to ultimately be “spent” at Bruce Wagner Consulting, not hoarded.

Anyway…

**You MUST WATCH this first.  Don’t be deceived by the title.  You need to watch this 7 minute video first:   http://www.digitalcoin.info/The_Essence_of_Money.html

Second,  this video translates the concepts of the first video, into the dual coin “Digital Coin” concept.  You must watch this 8 minute video:  http://www.digitalcoin.info/Digital_Coin_Introduction.html

Finally, read this 4 page article… where Paul describes the concept in detail:   http://www.digitalcoin.info/Digital_Coin_in_Brief_07-17-09.pdf

You must see these videos, and read that article, before any of this will really make sense. ** For example, NOW I understand what farmer_boy was saying earlier, when he said…

Quote from: farmer_boy on November 29, 2010, 8:54:02 PM UTC

Another money system is described on http://digitalcoin.info (this is what the Money as Debt 2 movie refers to). As with bitcoins, I see no formal specification of how it is supposed to work, but it seems to me to be a better system than bitcoins if you look at the kind of properties one would want to get out of a money system and those that are actually obtained.

Bitcoins are similar to the permanent digital coins type, but have the downside (or upside depending on your role) of having a purely speculative value. The credit coin has no counterpart in the Bitcoin system and as such doesn’t perform all functions one would like to get from a money system.

The author of bitcoins has a technical background, but less of an experience in money history (correct me if I am wrong). The designer of the digitalcoin probably has a less technical background, but a firm understanding of money and its history.

The most important feature that the digital coins have is that you never have the “we won’t do this project, because there is no money”-problem, which was what happened in 1929. There were workers, people wanting to eat, and factories, but no money.

Initially, it does seem rather complicated to make these kinds of credit coins contract (see the movie), but if one were to label ever product with a number (which already happens for a lot of products (e.g. a soda)), then it wouldn’t really be a problem.  

What are your thoughts on digital coin?

P.S. Is the guy from OpenTransactions also on this forum? It seems he has the broadest technical view as he has implemented a very wide range of systems and documented these on his website.

The overall idea proposed by Paul is a VERY intriguing concept…   And, from my viewpoint, they seem very much in concert with Bitcoin concepts… just an EXPANSION of the Bitcoin idea… from being only about VALUE… into the world of CREDIT…  Self-created credit.  Automatically-adjusted-value credit.  And Interest-Free credit.   Very interesting.  😊

Bruce Wagner December 1, 2010 23:13 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: farmer_boy on December 01, 2010, 9:30:43 PM UTC

I am just amazed that one guy build all these movies (and without asking money for it). Very inspiring. I wonder which tools he uses to get all of that done (which I am sure has taken him a decade to learn (as all experts need)). For me that’s just magic.

I think he lists alot of that information in the credits at the very end of each film.

Bruce Wagner December 2, 2010 02:08 UTC Link to this message

Continuing my correspondence with Paul Grignon of “Money As Debt II”…  I hope you find it interesting.

Hey says,

If I understand BitCoin correctly, it is a secure “digital object” that can be transferred directly peer-to-peer.  No accounting by a third party like PayPal.  Sounds the same as Digital Coin that far.

Yes, exactly.

There the similarity ends.  Perpetual Coin’s value for purchase with national currencies is to be determined by a convergence formula that will make it’s trajectory a smooth curve, a new ” global money unit” that removes the noise of currency volatility to leave a pure signal.  It is not free-floating like BitCoin initially.

Yes.  Bitcoin was designed to have a free-flowing value right from the start.  However, this might be considered a “bad” thing or a “good” thing.  One thing’s for sure, it easily demonstrates that the overall trendline of the value is always rising.   I think that helps people accept it.   Some people will even think of buying Bitcoin as “an investment”… like buying gold and silver.   If it were to remain at par for the USD, fewer people would be easily enticed into using it.   For example, the Liberty Dollar.   People would have to be sold only on its other merits.   My philosophy is:   It doesn’t matter which door they come in through.  What matters is that they are inside now.    It’s very important that masses of people accept Bitcoin… even if the only reason they got into it in the first place was, as a speculative investment.

It is also not a single uniform commodity like gold or silver in which the value depends on scarcity.

I thought I understood the video to say that the Perpetual Coin would be permanent and created in limited supply.

 Credit Coin is a delivery contract for specific goods and/or services from a specific promisor, just like a note payable in gold or silver was. But in this case it could be a note for anything in demand.  Demand for the actual product or service is what gives the Credit Coin its value.   It is always honoured in product or service by its Issuer at face value.

Yes.  So it appears to me like the Bitcoin is the Perpetual Coin.

Another issue that I don’t really see addressed anywhere, is this:

It seems like, with the second coin, the Credit Coin…   There would end up being millions and millions of different Coins — each issued by a different issuer.

This seems horribly complex.   How could any merchant possibly be expected to accept anything more than one or two forms of payment.   I think it would be highly unlikely that they would accept any coins other than coins that have solid value (the Perpetual Coin)… and coins that they issued themselves.   I cannot imagine a merchant being willing to accept even a dozen different “currencies” (in effect) --- Credit Coins issued by any of millions of possible issuers.

It seems to me like the Credit Coin is something that would be traded mostly online… by speculators… and discount seekers.   Like day-traders do today.   And like many people who buy discount coupons online now.   

I can also image a real problem with lack of interest in certain Credit Coins issued by obscure or new or unknown entities…  That lack of interest in trading them (buying and selling them on an exchange), could lead to severely under-priced Credit Coins…   And that could soon result in discouraging people from issuing them in the first place…  when they figure out that they are discounting their products/services far more than they feel is fair.

(2)   How can we help / participate in your “Money as Debt III” project…?

You might not like it as I present a case against the concept of money as a single uniform commodity, which gold, silver, fiat cash, bank credit, and BitCoin all are.

Nonetheless I like the presentation you have.  This is the time for a melting pot of new ideas.   I would say MAD III will probably be more radical than anything you have seen proposed before, other than Zeitgeist and the Venus Project’s  “No money at all” idea.

Wow.  I’m very anxious to see it now… 

Many concepts sound fantastic… in theory… on paper…  But selling normal people, common merchants, etc., on the idea… I can see that being one of the biggest hurdles.

Bruce

kiba December 9, 2010 14:36 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: nanaimogold on December 09, 2010, 1:26:49 PM UTC

As far as I can tell, the biggest obstacle to the acceptance of bitcoin is the dirty reputation of our self appointed cheerleader.

❓

Bruce Wagner January 7, 2011 19:31 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: FreeMoney on December 17, 2010, 11:40:02 PM UTC

I also think a promotor could better be a someone who is not from a minority group fom a marketing point of view and it should also be someone who picks the communication channels somewhat better.

It doesn’t matter if someone is better everyone who wants to will promote. This isn’t an election. Everyone is from some minority group anyway. I’m probably in 6.

I think Bruce is doing great work.

Wow.   See what happens when you start a thread and then get busy and don’t check back in until a month later…   😊

No one elected me promoter.    I’m just doing what I feel compelled to do.    If you don’t like it:

(1)   Ignore me. (2)   Make yourself a promoter.

It’s true that everyone is in at least a few minorities.    And if that’s so important to you, then become THE promoter yourself.    I’d be willing to bet that nanaimogold is in more minorities than I am.    But who the h*ll cares.    I really thought this was 2011.    Get with it, and get over it.   I’m gay.    If you don’t like it, don’t marry me.