Bitcoin Institute

One of the most important things Bitcoin needs in order to become mainstream

4 messages BitcoinTalk Bruce Wagner November 22, 2010 — November 23, 2010
Bruce Wagner November 22, 2010 03:39 UTC Link to this message

I was telling a merchant friend about Bitcoin today.

His first question / concern led me to this suggestion…


One of the most important things Bitcoin needs in order to become mainstream for transaction processing…  (besides an Android App that’s a front-end interface for instantaneous transactions from phone to phone, using MtGox or MyBitcoin as the back-end…)  is:

A “Recurring Subscription” Feature  -  Automatic Recurring Payments

It might be cool to integrate this feature into the standard Bitcoin App… as a  “Scheduled Transactions”  and/or  “Automatically Recurring Transactions”

Or, add the feature to web-based transaction sites, like MtGox and MyBitcoin…

I see it possibly working like this, for example:

A Merchant’s Shopping Cart, on the Merchant’s web site, could  “Request”  a “MtGox Subscription” from a Customer… (upon customer signing up for some service)…

Customer gets notified by email.

Customer must then log in to MtGox and click “CONFIRM” to confirm the new Subscription… thus creating a new Recurring Automatic Payment to that Merchant…of the same amount every month.

Then, every month, that amount will automatically be sent from Customer’s MtGox account to Merchant’s MtGox account (with payment/subscription record number).

This continues until Customer CANCELs that automatically recurring payment.


This feature --- the ability for a merchant to automatically get paid every month --- is absolutely essential for many types of businesses…  and it is a feature currently glaringly MISSING from Bitcoin as of now.

Bruce Wagner November 22, 2010 22:55 UTC Link to this message

Compared to you guys, I guess I am a total non-geek.   😉

I have no interest, and very limited skill, in writing even one line of code.   My merchant friends are not technical at all.   For example, one owns a restaurant - sort of a Chipotle for Middle Eastern food.    Another one does Prosperity Workshops.   (Don’t ask me what those are?!)   Another is a pop singing duo who sells access to a web site for donating fans.

In all these cases, they need something as easy to use, and as intuitive to use, as Google Search…

I was not suggesting that Recurring Payments be built-in to the standard client  ( although it’s possible that some future clients could include that )…  I was suggesting that someone like  MtGox.com  and/or  MyBitcoin.com  add these features.

The idea is…

For example, on my MtGox  “My Account”  page…   I’d see a list of  Recurring Payments.   That list would show me that I have the following recurring payments:

  •  Gold’s_Gym    BTC  200.00    1st day of every month      Memo: “Account 481238”            [Edit]  [Cancel this recurring payment]
  •  Arvixe.com    BTC   16.50     15th day of every month    Memo: “Username jazzyguy”        [Edit]  [Cancel this recurring payment]
  •  Put.io           BTC   16.50     25th day of every month    Memo: “loopydude”                    [Edit]  [Cancel this recurring payment]
  •  AdNetwork     USD  100.00    every week on Monday      Memo: “xxx-xxx-xxxx”               [Edit]  [Cancel this recurring payment]
  •  EFF               BTC  350.00    1st day of every month      Memo: “Thanks for all you do!”    [Edit]  [Cancel this recurring payment]

I, as the “Customer”, could initiate a recurring payment… of course.

And, just for the sake of convenience, the “Merchant” could initiate a “Request for a Recurring Payment”… via MtGox.   All it would do is email me (the Customer) a link.  When I click that link, it would automatically create a new Recurring Payment…  But require me to click  “ACCEPT AND ADD THIS REQUEST”  or  “CANCEL THIS REQUEST”.    If I click “Accept and Add”, then the details would be inserted for me automatically…  just to save me typing.   (This is important!  Customers are very very lazy!)

Many many many merchants reply on regular monthly subscriptions.   It’s not a bad thing…  as long as the Customer is in control of them.   Traditional banks offer “Online Bill Payment” systems, and they normally always have a Recurring Payments function.   It is essential.

Notice the entry for “AdNetwork” in my table above is listed in  “USD”, not BTC.  The idea is, the Merchant could require only USD to be paid… or only BTC.  It would work either way…  as long as I maintain a sufficient balance in the proper currency…  to accommodate the automatic recurring payments I have scheduled for my account.

Bruce Wagner November 22, 2010 23:56 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: creighto on November 22, 2010, 11:52:04 PM UTC

“Wendy?” “Yes, Lisa.”

LOL…   No…   You guys are so “straight-laced”, shall we say.    Showtime (the cable network in the US) made a movie about my friends lives…  They are:  http://jasonanddemarco.com

Email them and tell them you want to donate to them… in Bitcoin…  😉     ( Don’t mention me. )

Bruce Wagner November 23, 2010 00:48 UTC Link to this message

No…   just “straight”.    It’s not a bad thing.    😊