Bitcoin Institute

Who Controls Bitcoin?

3 messages BitcoinTalk Bruce Wagner November 10, 2010 — November 12, 2010
Bruce Wagner November 10, 2010 10:31 UTC Link to this message

Who maintains the bitcoin software?

Is it all open source?

Is it possible that someone could corrupt the software?

Is it possible that someone could use a modified version of the software to corrupt the bitciin chain?

I’ve seen references to some sort of security flaw which was fixed in the latest version of the software.  When a problem like this occurs, who steps in to fix it?  How does that process happen? 

Where can I read more about what happened, what went wrong, and how it was resolved?

Does one person (the creator?) have “the Master password” which could “unlock” the chain… allowing him to do such things as… modify the limit of 21 million bitcoins, for example?

If Intel were to release a CPU 1,000,000 times faster than the fastest current CPUs on the market today, (and internet connections suddenly became 1,000,000 times faster too), how would that affect bitcoin generation, and the bitcoin economy?

Who’s most “in charge of” or most “in control of” the bitcoin network?   What person(s) or entity(ies)?

Bruce Wagner November 10, 2010 18:20 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: grondilu on November 10, 2010, 12:39:10 PM UTC

Yeah I may have written rtfm a little too quickly.  I just felt like writing it when I red the first questions, especially “Is it open source ?”.

Yes, I already read the fine manual… before I posted.   

If I had found the answers to any of my questions in the manual, I wouldn’t be posting them here.   

And I didn’t post these questions on the first day I joined this forum.  I’ve been reading and reading and reading this forum…   

And I finally decided that it SHOULDN’T be this hard to find the answers to  — what I consider to be — very fundamental basic questions.

If I have this much difficulty finding these answers…  I can only imagine how difficult it must be for the average person.

And, by the way, RTFQ.

You misread my first question.  I didn’t say, “Is it open source?”  /   I said, “Is it ALL open source?”  (referring to the bitcoin software) 

In other words, are there any versions, or any components of any versions, that are NOT open source?

Bruce Wagner November 12, 2010 13:59 UTC Link to this message

Thanks, Gavin. Once I understand it all a bit more, myself, I may take you up on that, and see if I can contribute to the documentation front. For now, obviously, I’m still trying to learn and understand many of the basics. 

I just finished reading a thread about evaluation of the “anonymity” of bitcoin transactions. Wow. That made my head hurt a little.  Try answering THAT FAQ question in three sentences or less:  “Are bitcoin transactions anonymous?”  The only reasonably short, yet accurate, answer to that question is:  “No.  Not completely.”     😊