Bitcoin Institute

[Split topic] Speculation, capitalism, etc.

14 messages BitcoinTalk kiba, Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 — November 9, 2010
kiba November 9, 2010 02:18 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 2:06:55 AM UTC

I’m sorry, I know my words are strong … I understand that most people do not realize what they are doing. Can you call a child taking someone else’s apple a scumbag because he “stole it”? I do not think so … but it is expected that the child grows up and as a grown up is going to be held liable for the same action. It’s time to grow up 😉

It’s the intention that counts, from the outside it is very hard if not impossible to distinguish speculation and genuine demand. Of course if you buy bitcoins to do some business with them and in the meantime it rises you’re not speculator nor scumbag.

What gives bitcoin its value right now? What is backing it? There are not enough real useful services (meaning other than “let me try this” type of things which are driven by pure enthusiasm for the novelty of bitcoin - which is going to go away soon) so most of the apparent “value” is a bubble created by exactly the type of speculators hoping to make a profit. This is not real value … it’s virtual, it doesn’t exist … in the real world nobody values bitcoins for the sake of being bitcoins. It baffles my mind how anybody can see this as something good, why would it be good? For what? because it makes pretty charts? This type of economy is just a giant ponzi scheme snowballing and snowballing until there is enough suckers to believe it will go further up … when the world runs out of suckers people start selling off unleashing a raging inferno of sell-offs where those who sell off first are at the top of the pyramid making huge profits while the base is going to loose big time … in the end no real value or wealth was ever created, the money just changed hands (was redistributed) from the suckers to those at the top. there is not value in that … pretty charts showing rising numbers are not wealth. It’s fraud and a scam … the only real value is physical economy and services that people desire other than monetary gain. Selling “investment funds” for the sake of making more money from money is not a service anybody would desire if they wouldn’t want more money from it … the same goes for gambling, casinos etc. - NOBODY would participate if there wasn’t a prospect for making more money out of just money. This is the scam … that can’t be done, it’s zero sum game. You can NOT make money from money this way or create real wealth … you can just take it from somebody else - and that is just wrong and YES IT IS IMMORAL too! 😉

Regardless, you are still accusing me and others of stealing and scamming. I WILL HOLD YOU accountable for libel on bitcoin community members.

I will not trade with you, give you anything, and so on, to the best of my knowledge possible. In other words, if I found you using ANY of my web app that I am building right now or in the future, I will suspend your accounts. I will tell other people to boycott you until you apologize for your fallacious libels.

Is that clear?

kiba November 9, 2010 02:56 UTC Link to this message

I am proud of this community. Despite Macho’s insults, you guys play it swell and didn’t insult Macho back.

kiba November 9, 2010 03:18 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 3:13:58 AM UTC

Glad I don’t live in a world with your moralities.

Yeah, I’m sure you enjoy seeing millions of men, women and children die of starvation all the time because some investment banker is taking his next big business into fruition. But I’m considered “immoral” for calling that banker scum … and I’m supposed to be the one with values upside down?   So let’s worship speculation and get offended by people calling scam a scam so we can ignore reality, sleep well at night and make some awesome profit without our conscience being moved.

I’m sad that I actually live in a world with moralities like yours 😞

Bitcoin is a capitalistic idea. What do you expect? Tree hugging hippies?

kiba November 9, 2010 03:46 UTC Link to this message

I don’t know what you Macho and bober182 see in bitcoins.

Especially when the economy is inhabited and controlled by the very people you hate.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 04:14 UTC Link to this message

I think that, often, “what makes economic sense”… is also what helps the masses most.  Money, like water, usually flows downward… toward where it is needed most.  For example, labor is cheapest in countries where money is needed most.  Labor is most expensive in countries where people are too rich, fat, and happy to want to perform labor. Of course, tyrant dictators often control the money and the power in their respective countries… But not forever.  As that nation prospers more and more, one of two things tends to happen: (1)  They share the wealth with the laborers who are creating it. Result: They end up fat and happy and no longer the cheapest labor in the world. Or, (2) They greedily keep it all for themselves and let the laborers work more like a slave class. Result: Eventually the divide between the have’s and have-not’s grows wider and wider, until there is a revolution, and the dictator(s) are toppled. In the end, this seems to be good for everyone.  Of course, these things don’t happen overnight.  Maybe not even in one generation.  But they do happen over time. Taiwan used to be impoverished.  They were known for making the cheapest plastic crap toys, and later Christmas tree lights.  Because they are capitalist and free, over time, the country prospered greatly… eventually holding the largest foreign cash reserves of any nation.   Now, they make computers, laptops, and other very sophisticated tech products.  The cheap plastic toy manufacturing moved to Malaysia and China.   The tide rolls on.   Now, China is advancing.   More and more sophisticated electronics are being manufactured there.   As the search for ever-cheaper labor continues…  the money flows to where it’s needed most…  over time.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 04:54 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 1:14:17 AM UTC

…the speculators are buying rice for the sole purpose of selling it at higher price so net effect is that the rice is more expansive than it would be if the market was untampered with (not manipulated) with a cut going to the speculator. The speculator does nothing else than take the cut. There is no value added, he just steals the money counting on the fact that regular people do not have the time or desire to watch for such a thing (because they are honest and actually producing real goods rather than feeding off of someone else’s work)…

Sorry.  But this logic is so… shall we say…   “flawed”.  ( To say the least.  …and to be kind. )

Let me ask you this:  When the speculators LOSE money, who is stealing from whom?   Huh?    Who is the thief then?

Remember, speculators LOSE money just about as often as the MAKE money.   That’s why it’s called speculation.   So…  When they LOSE money…  Who is the thief?  

By your logic…    YOU are.

Speculators are to a currency… like the thermostat is to your furnace.   When it’s too hot, they automatically decrease the temperature.   When it’s too cold, they automatically increase the temperature.   Speculators may make for more volatile swings in the value.   However, when the value is higher than it should be, they sell… bringing the value down.   When the value is lower than it should be, they buy… bringing the value up.   Speculation is a necessary, beneficial, essential component of a free market.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 05:03 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 4:32:29 AM UTC

It makes economic sense to run sweatshops and even slaves (if they are not going to rise up that is), I doubt anybody would consider that “helping the masses”.

This is just plain false.   As long as those workers are voluntarily working there, they are BETTER OFF.   Would you rather have them work hard for 20 cents an hour, or have their family starve to death.   Those are your two choices.   Which do you choose?

I can tell you for sure:  If you ask them…   They will tell you that the day they got that job… in the “sweatshop”…  on the cruise line… whatever… for 20 cents an hour…  THAT day felt like they had won the lottery.

So, that IS helping the masses.    Directly.

And, as I said, those workers will eventually either become prosperous and live a better life… or they WILL rise up and overthrow their dictator…   Either way, it does benefit those masses.

kiba November 9, 2010 05:40 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 5:38:04 AM UTC

Capitalism is not liberalism.   The former is compatible with slavery, the latter is not.

In a capitalist world, slaves could be considered as a mean of production, like any other.  But such a society would not be liberal.

The thing is : most people here are BOTH capitalists AND liberals.    Well, at least I am.

OK … is liberalism compatible with sweatshops then? Toxic waste? ponzi schemes? If not, why not?

I think we are not understanding each other in one pretty obscure point, I’ll try to explain once I know you answer so i can see if I’m right …

You went batshit crazy for two thread and accuse us of all sort of stuff that we didn’t endorse.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 05:48 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 5:24:30 AM UTC

If the speculators would be losing money they wouldn’t speculate…

Oh, come on.  That’s like saying, “If gamblers lost money, they wouldn’t gamble.”    If that were true, Las Vegas would not exist.   Even you know that gamblers don’t always win.  In fact, they lose much more often than they win.

Anyway, I think some of your sentiments are close…  But you keep missing the target.

You seem to have been brainwashed a little bit by the media and other “powers that be”…

The cause of our current Wall St economic woes is NOT due to speculators.   There’s nothing wrong with speculation.   Speculation is as old as money itself.

The cause of much of our current economic woes is simple FRAUD.   It’s from creating paper that’s worthless, then having the most reputable rating firms declare it GOOD and SAFE.

That is just plain FRAUD --- nothing more, nothing less.

FRAUD is not capitalism.   Fraud is fraud.   It’s just criminal activity plain and simple.   But don’t buy into this “blame the speculators” BS.   That’s just an excuse to let the guilty off the hook.

Meanwhile, I view corporations as simply “machines to make money”.  They have no conscious whatsoever.  To expect them to have a conscious is as ridiculous as expecting your refrigerator to have a conscious.   Rampant corporatology, and government collusion with global corporations leads to more corruption… usually with very bad results for the masses.  That’s why it’s up to governments to regulate and control corporations…  keeping them in line.   For example, Walmart has basically BECOME a China company… representing China’s interests far more than American interests.   That’s what happens with a “machine to make money”…  It just gets more and more efficient at making money… until it eventually crosses the line… and goes too far.

Anyway, capitalism is not to blame.  And speculation is not to blame.   The people need to educate themselves more about how things work.   Perpetrators of fraud must be punished.  And corporations need to be reigned in and controlled by the government.

kiba November 9, 2010 05:53 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 5:48:57 AM UTC

I think we are not understanding each other in one pretty obscure point, I’ll try to explain once I know you answer so i can see if I’m right …

You went batshit crazy for two thread and accuse us of all sort of stuff that we didn’t endorse. that goes both ways I believe but I don’t mind … btw if you endorse intentional speculation for the sole purpose of profit then I’m still calling you a scumbag 😄 LOL

I did not accuse you of that, you confessed it 😉

I believe that kind of speculation is wrong, morally wrong, just like sweatshops are in my view and I’m not going to endorse it. On the contrary I’m going to speak out against it as I would against owners or practitioners of sweatshops … and I would also call them scumbags 😛

But you did say I endorse polluting the environment, slavery, amongst other things. I have no problem with speculation and owning factories but I do have a problem with slavery, polluting the environments, and such.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 06:01 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 5:48:57 AM UTC

I believe that kind of speculation is wrong, morally wrong, just like sweatshops are in my view and I’m not going to endorse it. On the contrary I’m going to speak out against it as I would against owners or practitioners of sweatshops … and I would also call them scumbags 😛

I know, personally, two people who grew up in two different countries… but both had this in common:  They worked in sweatshops most of their life.  And they would be the first to tell you…  They thank GOD for those sweatshops.   If it hadn’t been for those sweatshops, they and their families would have likely starved to death.   

One of these families was in Taipei, Taiwan about 40 years ago.   The other one was in Miami, Florida about 45 years ago.

Sweatshops are just like any other productive capitalist business.  If the workers are working there out of their own free will, they are almost always EXTREMELY grateful for their job there.

The irony is:  Those who would call sweatshops immoral are fat, rich, and happy… living in rich Western countries… and have probably never even SEEN true hunger before in their lives.   Yet, they want to judge the sweatshops as evil…  while the workers are thanking God for them, and calling them a blessing from God.

Speculation is not immoral.  Gambling is not immoral.   The only time it’s bad is if you are doing it too much… to the point that it is harming YOU.   Then it’s a problem.

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 06:14 UTC Link to this message

@creighto   Your posts are very entertaining.  I laughed out loud a couple of times.  Thanks.  😊

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 17:03 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: Macho on November 09, 2010, 5:48:57 AM UTC

btw if you endorse intentional speculation for the sole purpose of profit then I’m still calling you a scumbag 😄 LOL

What about “speculation for the sole purpose of LOSING money”…  Are you saying that That’s ok with you…?   ha ha

Speculation and “Ponzi schemes”… are simply gambling.  Nothing more and nothing less.   Gambling.    By DEFINITION, gambling involves risk — great risk.   That means they often LOSE all of the money they’re playing with.

You can say that gambling is “morally wrong”.   But I totally disagree.   If the player of the game understands the terms and rules of the game, then it’s certainly fair for them to play that game.

It harms no one.   (Unless they do it compulsively, to their own detriment.  But that’s an entirely different topic.  Like drinking so much water that you drown yourself.  Too much of anything can kill you.)

In fact, YOUR very own bitcoin holdings are likely worth much more today than they were last month.  Likely, that increase in value is at least partially a result of investment by speculators.   So, since you believe that that increase in value is “morally wrong”…  Obviously, it would be “morally wrong” to profit from it (even though you took no risks at all, by the way. none whatsoever.)…  Who are you going to donate all that increased value to?   Some charity?  Some anti-gambling organization?   Of course, by your own logic…  It would be “morally wrong” for you to keep any increase in its value.    Right?!?

Bruce Wagner November 9, 2010 17:12 UTC Link to this message

I think this kinda sums up how I feel too…

Quote from: kiba on November 09, 2010, 2:56:12 AM UTC

I am proud of this community. Despite Macho’s insults, you guys play it swell and didn’t insult Macho back.