Bitcoin Institute

Price Deflation Discourage Investment?

5 messages BitcoinTalk kiba October 15, 2010 — October 25, 2010
kiba October 15, 2010 15:24 UTC Link to this message

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1794532

I’m sorry, but this statement alone convinces me that there are important facts about economics which you do not understand. Deflation, among many other things, discourages investment. Without investment, economies stagnate. -btilly on Hacker News.

I feel cognitive dissonance. The bitcoin community’s overall investment seem to be increasing not stagnating. I also know the computer industry is spending lot of money on their factories and plants while the price of computers continue to lower.

kiba October 15, 2010 15:43 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: theymos on October 15, 2010, 3:42:04 PM UTC

The bitcoin community’s overall investment seem to be increasing not stagnating.

Bad argument. 7200 BTC are created daily.

Continuous price deflation?

kiba October 15, 2010 20:50 UTC Link to this message

creighto: Thank you for advancing my economic knowledge. That was helpful.

I already incorporated time preference and the observation that the bitcoin economy is experiencing growth deflation.

kiba October 16, 2010 14:13 UTC Link to this message

He proposed dollars as an explanatory mechanism for why the bitcoin economy simply doesn’t implode.

I submit to you that investment in the bitcoin economy is paid for in other currencies (eg dollars), not in bitcoins. Given that, the strength of the bitcoin economy has nothing to do with the availability of money for investment. And indeed a growth in value for bitcoins should drive investment in bitcoins, which leads to what you’ve observed.

I don’t know. The computer industry doesn’t seem to be imploding. Investment in semiconductor fabrication plants are becoming more expensive why the products are in deflationary sprial.(Perhaps that is not a good example since fabrication plant investment cost are offset by inflations?)

kiba October 25, 2010 23:57 UTC Link to this message
Quote from: grondilu on October 25, 2010, 9:11:00 PM UTC

It’s important to be clear whether we’re talking about price deflation or monetary deflation. I think we can all agree that a stable supply (quantity) of money is economically ideal and under this environment, rising of falling prices are just a consequence of economic growth or contraction.

I think we also agree that manipulation of the supply of money, whether it be by governments or banks, creates a misallocation of resources which destabilizes the economy making us poorer.

I’m not sure about the first paragraph, but I perfectly agree with the second.

I don’t think there’s anything economically ideal about a stable supply of money. I think people are happy with the ability to predict the growth of the money supply.