Bitcoin without mining
So I’ve been thinking… bitcoin mining seems like such an unfortunate side effect of the system since it is so wasteful. It will be a bit obscene how much will be spent mining if the network ever gets large. It would be cool to come up with a bitcoin that doesn’t need miners.
There are several issues but Ill ignore how coins are distributed and focus on the central problem of creating some way to trust the central ledger*. Currently this is what mining solves. The network trusts the ledger with the most mining done on it. So now to trust bitcoin you have to trust that >50% of the current mining power is “good”. And actually the way the network has evolved with pools we are actually trusting that every large pool operator is good since even if the pool isnt over 50% the operator could have non-pool mining going on bringing the total over 50% or two pools could collude to defraud the network etc. Also if say some government decides to wreck the network it wouldnt be that expensive for them to do so. (This is all discussed in other threads so no need to go into this here) My point is that although the current network uses mining as a way to solve the trust issue it really doesnt since you still must trust the large pool operators.
My idea is to make this issue of trust explicit.
Lets say a node has a public key that the client generates for them. There is no connection between this key and a wallet key. It just allows you to be sure you are talking to the node you think you are.
So when you run a node you choose which other nodes you trust. So you could say I trust my 3 friends nodes, Gavins node, and these 5 businesses nodes. This trust just means that you believe these people will never participate in a double spend attack or otherwise manipulate the ledger. The ledger would basically be like the current bitcoin block chain but it would also have a list of what nodes believe the current ledger to be valid. <hash of current ledger signed by nodes public key> (This list doesnt have to be complete. Nodes can just collect this list as needed. They could even just ask the nodes they trust if they think the current ledger is valid since those are the only ones they care about)
Transactions are still sent to all nodes connected to the network. There would be a network wide timestamp. Transactions would only be accepted if they were within a certain time period of the network timestamp. So you would need to wait maybe 10min before you could fully trust a given transaction. After this waiting period you could be sure those coins werent double spent.
If a node ever encounters two conflicting ledgers it would just go with the one that was validated by more nodes that it trusts.
So there should always be a consensus among the trusted members of the network.
There would be a way to look up particular nodes in the network and ask them questions. (Im imagining this whole thing running on Kademlia, a DHT)
So obviously this is still vague because I haven’t had time to work out all the details. Im hoping someone else will be inspired.
ok rip into it!
*(I guess you could try to come up a way to get rid of the central ledger but I have a feeling that might not be possible)
