Re: Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency

Hi Satoshi,

we are actually really talking about the old Chaumian central stuff. That was because a) it was there b) it was patent free (we have to think a bit about the US). I had a read of your paper on the weekend - thanks a lot for doing that work. Interesting read.

What I did not understand about your system - how would you use it for a currency of any sort? Everybody can create a coin as they like, as far as I understood, so therefore there is no trusted supply of tokens / coins. Or the other way around: if you don’t trust the double spending database, because its a central instance, you surely couldn’t trust a central issuer to issue and redeem. How would a currency work otherwise? Would you use it for a mutual credit system in which the transactions are shown online?

Cheers,

Joerg

Original Source

https://web.archive.org/web/20090221024857/http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topics/bitcoin-open-source#2003008Comment9543
Originally posted to the P2P Foundation Ning forum (since defunct). Preserved via the Wayback Machine snapshot dated 2009-02-21; timestamp is the post's site-displayed time.