Re: Bitcoin open source implementation of P2P currency

Joerg Baach February 17, 2009 10:42 UTC

Hi Satoshi,

we are actually really talking about the old Chaumian central stuff. That was because a) it was there b) it was patent free (we have to think a bit about the US). I had a read of your paper on the weekend - thanks a lot for doing that work. Interesting read.

What I did not understand about your system - how would you use it for a currency of any sort? Everybody can create a coin as they like, as far as I understood, so therefore there is no trusted supply of tokens / coins. Or the other way around: if you don’t trust the double spending database, because its a central instance, you surely couldn’t trust a central issuer to issue and redeem. How would a currency work otherwise? Would you use it for a mutual credit system in which the transactions are shown online?

Cheers,

Joerg

Original external source

https://web.archive.org/web/20090221024857/http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topics/bitcoin-open-source#2003008Comment9543
Originally posted to the P2P Foundation Ning forum (since defunct). Preserved via the Wayback Machine snapshot dated 2009-02-21; timestamp is the post's site-displayed time.